Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Saving Linux cash on Vista clunkers

My friend Joe Eckert recently penned a short, funny piece entitled, "Does Tech Need a Boost? How About "Cash for Vista?". After I got done smiling at it, I thought: why not offer desktop Linux to people with Vista clunkers? Seriously, why not?

Microsoft owes it to its Vista customers to offer them a free upgrade to Windows 7, as Windows 7 is really just a massive Vista service patch. There are no new significant features in Windows 7. You'd think that Microsoft, which has been having one bad quarter after another, would want to be nice to its customers — but no, that's not going to happen.

So, since Microsoft won't give Windows 7 to people stuck with Vista clunkers, why doesn't a Linux vendor do it instead? Say you just send an e-mail into a Linux distributor, and they'll send you a URL to a Web site where they can download a brand-spanking new copy of a top desktop Linux for free! What a deal!

What's that? Yes, I know Linux is free, but they don't know that! If they think they're getting a bargain maybe they'll finally start giving Linux a try.

Seriously, though, I think some of the Linux vendors should consider this idea. Instead of just offering them a vanilla Linux distribution, they could put together a package that includes CodeWeavers' CrossOver Linux for Windows applications, and modify the desktop so it has a familiar Vista (say KDE 4.3) or XP (KDE 3.5.x) look.

If you'd rather not use CrossOver Linux for Windows applications, there's always Wine, Crossover's foundation. Or make a point of putting common Windows program replacements like OpenOffice for Microsoft Office and GnuCash for Quicken front and center so Vista users can easily get up to speed.

I wish there was an easy-to-use Windows-to-Linux desktop migration program, but the best of that lot, Versora Progression Desktop, has not been available since 2007, when Versora was bought out by Kaseya, an IT Managed Services Automation firm. While Kaseya promised that Versora's functionality would still be available, I couldn't find it any of Kaseya's currently shipping products — and, in any case, Kaseya's customers are businesses, not individual desktop Linux or Windows users. If there are any programmers out there who want an idea that could make a profitable little product, I think you could do well with a Windows to Linux migration tool.

Still, just throw in some basic Windows/Linux interoperability tools such as the NTFS-3G driver so Vista users could keep their existing files and directories, and I think you just find some Vista users who will be happy to become desktop Linux users. After all, since Microsoft isn't going to help them, Vista users already need all the help they can to move to a better, more reliable operating system. So, why not Linux for Vista clunkers? Think about it.

What People Are Saying

Triple-booting with my Vista "clunker"

5 year-old HP-Compaq multi-media laptop with 1.5 GB RAM (upgraded from 512 MB RAM for Windows XP Pro), 1.6 GB AMD single-core processor (with no multi-threading) and an integrated nVidia 64 MB video card.

Original OS: Windows XP Home

Replaced with Windows XP Professional (full license)

Added Debian Lenny via net-install (dual-boot)

Very recently upgraded (via custom install) from XP Home to Vista Home Premium 32-bit (triple-boot).

HP's video card and TI's media card drivers for XP 32-bit worked like a charm for Vista 32-bit. Downloaded a Vista driver from Realtek for their ethernet NIC and it is working just fine. No Aero interface with a 64 MB video card, but I don't care. I do get 1280x800 screen resolution which does matter to me.

This was just an experiment to see how good or poorly Vista would do on a relatively old laptop without gaming-quality hardware. Overall, it runs very well.

My Vista "clunker" security:
o Windows firewall (default)
o Address Space Layout Randomization (default)
o Internet Explorer protected mode (default)
o Windows Defender real-time protection (default)
o Data Execution Prevention for ALL programs (not default)
o a "real" standard user account (not default)
o Software Restriction Policy enabled via Parental Controls for standard user account (not default)

Seeing is believing

I am a semi-proffesional web-designer. I install many Linux Desktops on 56 - 65 year old's infected Win systems. These small business owners had never heard of linux.

A Puppy Linux CD (only 60 - 80MB!!) into the dead Win computers a few press OK's 5 minutes later a OS with full Suit of Microsoft compatible apps that feel familiar. The immediate program response times, virus free internet blow them away. This leads to a full installation of a more supported Linux distro I have found ex Win users like Linux Mint.

Seeing IS believing.

?

Why would a company give away a product for free when the market is excited about it?

??

Why should a company suddenly start charging for a product "when the market is excited about it"?

Start free, improve, get popular, improve, go commercial?

http://www.downloadsquad.com/2009/01/19/find-freeware-versions-of-commercial-apps-with-last-freeware-ver/
"Find freeware versions of commercial apps with Last Freeware Version

http://www.321download.com/LastFreeware/index.html
"Last Freeware Version

TheKritic chimes in....

Instead of getting cash for clunkers, we should try to get it recalled as defective and let MS replace it with Windows 7.Yes, I agree that Win7 should be free to Vista users. I bought Vista Ultimate 64bit on a new laptop and it crawls, but I wont get it free because of when I bought it. I think this is a sign that MS is not truely listening to its customers, they should have fixed Vista not released a new version that we have to pay for to fix their problems.

I actually run VMWare workstation and run XP and Linux VMs for better peformance, I also have from technet Windows 2008R2 and Win7 running, very nicely. I have done tech support, QA and now doing network admin work (all windows based) for large multi national software company, I am willing to help test Windows to Linux conversions apps.

For those that dont think Linux works, tell that to APPLE or maybe GOOGLE...

For Jason that mentioend it (win7) does not exsit to the public yet, I disagree. It has been made available to enough companies and people to be considered public, its not in retail yet, but it is public.

Cash for Clunkers

Maybe the Linux community ought to scrap up some money for some TV ads. "OS Hunters". Find an OS for less than $50 and you can keep the change. "Windows, it's cute, but it seems to be all about the hype. I guess I'm not cool enough for Windows. Oh, a FREE OS, gosh this Linux is so easy to use, much better than Windows."

Cash for Clunkers

Just a minor point, but you'll notice that Steven isn't talking about windows 7, since windows 7 has received such solidly good reviews all around. See google for more details.

He'll keep harping on the old version to see how much mileage he can get out of it. Please, continue..

Maybe you didn't notice

Maybe you failed to notice the following quote, "as Windows 7 is really just a massive Vista service patch."

Maybe that's because windows

Maybe that's because windows 7 is not out. It would be wrong to continue to report on an OS that does not exist to the public yet. Next time you make a comment, DON'T.