Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


IT Blogwatch's picture
IT Blogwatch

A Daily Digest of IT Blogs from Richi Jennings

Microsoft's Apple Store employee theft shocker!

Microsoft has been accused of stealing Apple employees. Specifically, retail store managers and sales people. In IT Blogwatch, bloggers watch the tidal flow from Apple Store to Microsoft Store.

By Richi Jennings. September 22, 2009.

Your humble blogwatcher has selected these bloggy morsels for your enjoyment. Not to mention ragtime Star Wars...
(MSFT) (AAPL)

Jim Dalrymple broke the story, citing anonymous tipsters:

Microsoft is beginning looking to Apple for more than just inspiration for its retail stores. ... Microsoft has contacted a number of Apple’s retail store managers to work in their stores. In addition to “significant raises,” the managers have also been offered moving expenses.
...
Once hired, the ex-Apple employees are then contacting some of the top sales people in the Apple retail organization offering them positions at Microsoft retail. They have also been offered more money than what they made at Apple. ... A smart move. Whether it will work or not remains to be seen.more


Emil Protalinski explains:

This move makes perfect sense from a business perspective (retail employees with some decent technological knowledge are hard to come by), but since Microsoft will be directly competing with Apple once it opens its retail stores, some find it odd that the same people who sell Apple products may be soon selling Microsoft products. Managerial and sales skills are, however, very transferable.
...
[There's] a webpage just for retail positions. If you work in an Apple store near a soon-to-be-opened Microsoft store, apparently the software giant is giving you a free pass; no looking through job postings necessary!more


Jennifer van Grove adds two and two and two:

If rumors are to be believed, now everything from the store design to the Guru Bars, and the actual staffers will have been plucked by Microsoft in an effort to compete in the retail space. The question remains if these aggressive tactics will pay off. We tend think that consumers will buy the better products, but Apple’s unique approach to the retail space has been widely successful.more


Eric Slivka sees a pattern here:

The company's retail stores are not the only arena where the Microsoft has attempted to gain a running start by tapping into the Apple ecosystem. Microsoft has also been reported to have offered significant sums of money to certain iPhone developers in order to entice them to port their applications to the new Zune HD platform.more


Michael Klurfeld calls it "a pretty smart move":

Grabbing up Apple store people is sort of brilliant because it means that Microsoft is largely drawing from a body pre-screened for various qualities. At least in my experience, Apple retail store employees are generally very good with people, and more so than the normal tech employee.  The other characteristic, and this is certainly true of the retail stores in New York, is that Apple’s retail staff has that same aesthetic attractiveness (yes, they’re pretty people) and fun vibe that Apple likes to put into its product lines.

That is the exact image that Microsoft has been trying to play up for itself.more


Bryan Chaffin observes irony:

In some cases, they may get to do this next door to or near their former employers -- in a word, that should be fun.
...
We should also add that such poaching is common practice in the world of high-dollar, corporate retail, though the practice doesn't often seem quite so ironic.more


Jonny Evans asks:

Bear in mind the background: Microsoft’s sales fell another 17 per cent in the just gone quarter as profits slid an astonishing 29 per cent. Sales fell to $13.1 billion, a billion short of analyst expectations and the second quarter of decline.
 
Will a chain of highly expensive retail shops truly be enough for Microsoft to regain relevancy?more


So what's your take?
Get involved: leave a comment.

 
Richi Jennings, your humble blogwatcherRichi Jennings is an independent analyst/consultant, specializing in blogging, email, and security. A cross-functional IT geek since 1985, he is also an analyst at Ferris Research. You can follow him as @richi on Twitter, or richij on FriendFeed, pretend to be richij's friend on Facebook, or just use good old email: itblogwatch@richij.com.
 
 

And finally...

 


 
 
Don't miss out on IT Blogwatch:

What People Are Saying

Microsoft Poaching Apple

So let me get this straight. Microsoft is going to try to play "catch up" to Apple.

Isn't that the very same thing people have been accusing Linux developers of doing?

Or on the other hand wasn't that what Microsoft was trying to do when it stole the graphic users interface from Apple? (Acknowledging of course Xerox Labs to start with.)

So what hardware is Microsoft going to offer in their retail stores? The MS Mouse and Keyboard, maybe the Xbox or the Zune. The reason they need a dedicated retail store for these items is because? Or maybe they will turn them into GameSpot type stores, selling Xbox game consoles with access to a bunch of third party games. Before you forget it, Apple stores sell very little Apple software. They do, however sell some third party software. They don't have the retail store to sell software. It's to sell Macs, MacBooks, iPods, iPhones and other hardware. They service Apple hardware also.

Is Microsoft going to carry every brand Window's 7 will install on? I can see it now, walls covered with shelves of computers of every make and size and price point. Like walking into a sporting goods store. Will they help you install Windows 7 on a System 76 computer? (Which only comes pre-installed with Linux. Obviously if you can convert it to Windows you are increase your market share. A clear win for Microsoft.)

I can't really fault Apple employees for switching to Microsoft. An individual should be free to work for whoever will hire them. But don't ask me what they'll do when Microsoft discovers the effort is nothing but an expensive financial drain and gets tired of them trying to provide real customer service. Microsoft has worked on the marketing principal that they have a monopoly, and the way to maintain that monopoly it to use it to lock out competition. They don't know how to do customer service. (Microsoft obviously doesn't know how to do it, or they wouldn't need to steal Apple employees. The question is, will they do what is necessary to provide that service? Remember SideKick employees?) When's the last time you tried to contact Microsoft Help? The hardware vendors point to Microsoft and Microsoft points to the hardware vendors, neither accepting responsibility for the fiasco on your desk top. Apple accepts responsibility for problems, (they've no one else to blame), Microsoft shovels crud, then blames it on the hardware vendor. (You need to get an updated driver for your hardware, sorry, they've had oodles and oodles of time to update them for the new OS. I suppose after two years, most of them do have halfway reasonable drivers by now.)

As far as the Apple employee is concerned, I would guess that this is one of those occasions when switching jobs does mean you are burning your bridges behind you.

apples and oranges

It's all well and good, but I suspect most of those employees all use and enjoy their apple products at home!

Have you ever BEEN to an apple store?

Wow this seems like a horrible mistake. Apple store staff are just as inept as any other retail chain worker making $9/hr but they also come with a sense of unjustified smug self superiority that Apple has always been known for.

BestBuy?

After all the trouble Microsoft went through to brainwash BestBuy employees wrt Linux, why didn't they hire retail staff from BestBuy?

I mean, they've been selling Microsoft stuff for years. And they have the dogma down pat: "Microsoft good, Apple bad, Linux bad." No need for retraining.

Because best Buy people

Because best Buy people talked down to customers, and Apple employees talk up to them. Retraining BB employees just wouldn't be possible - they're approach to selling computers was hardly above a thug mentality. I shuttered traveling for business and needing a quick acessory/part. Just walking about BB made me want to talk a shower.

Apple stores are successful because they sell potential an focus on what is possible. I think they're idea of decentralized checkout is a mess (in busy stores you can't flag anyone down to check out - I'd rather stand in a line) but otherwise, it's a store you can walk into for the sheer inspiration of it.

A broad brush

I've been in BestBuy stores as well. My own experience is that BestBuy staff listened, asked questions and offered suggestions, many good ones. Some were actually knowledgeable about Windows PCs and peripherals. Of course, the quality of service varied from one individual to the next as it always does. Some better, some worse.

The point is that BestBuy sells Windows PCs exclusively. The staff have a big jump on the product, Windows PCs.

The interview process continues to be important. The goal is to separate the wheat from the chaff.

Your point is that product knowledge is unimportant in retail. But for many, image is everything. Product and service quality are also important for successful retail. We're talking Microsoft here, so maybe you are right.

"The point is that BestBuy sells Windows PCs exclusively. "?

All the ones I've been in have Mac displays as well as PCs.

Trolle sal nie gevoed kan word

                            __________________________
                   /|  /|  |                          |
                   ||__||  |       Please don't       |
                  /   O O\__           feed           |
                 /          \       the trolls        |
                /      \     \                        |
               /   _    \     \ ----------------------
              /    |\____\     \     ||               
             /     | | | |\____/     ||               
            /       \|_|_|/   |    __||               
           /  /  \            |____| ||               
          /   |   | /|        |      --|             
          |   |   |//         |____  --|             
   * _    |  |_|_|_|          |     \-/               
*-- _--\ _ \     //           |                       
  /  _     \\ _ //   |        /                       
*  /   \_ /- | -     |       |                       
  *      ___ c_c_c_C/ \C_c_c_c____________

Troll?

http://arstechnica.com/microsoft/news/2009/09/microsoft-helps-best-buy-employees-troll-mac-users-too.ars

http://arstechnica.com/microsoft/news/2009/09/microsoft-teaches-best-buy-employees-how-to-troll-linux-users.ars

http://blogs.zdnet.com/BTL/?p=23945
"Microsoft training materials teach Best Buy employees how Windows beats Linux, Mac

I realize that the above examples do not necessarily prove the case against Microsoft. But, it's not just the trolls as you imply.

Microsoft employees: Go buy a Mac!

Doesn't Micro$oft realize that hiring evangelical Apple employees will lead them to secretly disuade people from buying a Windows PC?