Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Seth Weintraub's picture
Seth Weintraub

Apple versus Google

Google's Chrome OS will make a good 'second computer'

Google's vision for Chrome OS isn't going to replace what is on your desk now ... unless you are working and reading this on a netbook, that is.  

If you are — my condolences — that's no way to live.  Netbooks are good for fun stuff, but they aren't great for getting work done.  Cramped keyboards, slow processors, small screens are no way to live.  If you spend time on your computer, as lots of us do, every optimization saves us lots of time and money

It reminds me of the Chris Rock sketch where he mentions that, "you can drive a car with your feet, it doesn't mean it is a good $#@#%ing idea".

Google is realistic about this though.  Google doesn't want the desktop market, at least initially.  They want to own the Netbook market.  Even with (or should I say because of) the lousy economy, this market has been blowing up for the past few years and continues to do so. 

One major reason is because most Americans already have a PC, but more and more of us are opting for that second machine.  The machine to take on trips, to use before going to bed or outside on the deck (and yes the bathroom, so I've heard).

Windows wasn't meant for Netbooks.  XP was designed in 2002, 5 years before ASUS delivered the first Eee.  Vista was a dog on Netbooks and 7 isn't much better (and is being crippled by Microsoft).  There really just isn't a match there.

Google hopes to exploit this by not just designing an OS for today's netbooks.  They are designing an OS for tomorrow's netbooks.  By only utilizing SSDs and running all of their applications in the cloud, Google's OS will have a slew of advantages over Microsoft and even some solid Linux variants that don't have the mainstream branding that Google has.

But, like I said earlier, if you spend your day working on a computer, you are still going to want native apps for a lot of what you do.  Even things like email and calendar often work better with a native application even though Google's work almost as good.

As a second computer however, Google's product seems perfect.  Especially at the low netbook or lower prices. 

What People Are Saying

Google Chrome

The first operating system from Google is going to released in this year. This new operating is labeled as Google Chrome. It is going to be released as a Open Source operating system. It is believed to be a Linux kind of an operating system. Designed specially for Internet Users. For latest updates on Google Chrome OS and other related information you may visit the following site which was quite helpful for me.
http://www.techarena.in/guide/18410-whats-new-google-chrome-os.htm

Google Crome OS

Is Google Crome a stand alone Operaiting sytom.

Right now, I am using Window

Right now, I am using Window Vista and its pretty slow in comparison with my hardware configuration of computer so I am eagerly waiting for Google's Operating System.

Great!

Well written, funny, and true (even the computer in the bathroom part).

Imperfect

Seth Weintraub concludes this story saying that ChromeOS appliances seem like perfect second computers.

Unfortunately, no such thing as perfection exists for any computer. Functionality exists, but so does evolution. For every vision that Google has regarding these devices, the future has a trump card.

author you are dumb for

author you are dumb for saying that you cannot have a netbook as a primary computer. i use my netbook as my primary computer. I have the asus 1000HE and it works great! i use it for work and school. i type, surf, watch hulu, etc. yeh, if you're doing heavy work like media, get something else, but for the average joe, a netbook works great!

netbook vs. Chrome OS-limited netbook

I agree for the most part. My own first IBM PC certainly was my primary computer and suited my needs quite nicely, with a 4.7 MHz processor and, eventually, 640 MB of RAM. Certainly, a typical netbook outguns one of those handily. In fact, the hardware for a Chrome OS-class machine allows for a great deal of computing power. I still get great use out of a 600 MHz Pentium and 256 MB of RAM running Linux on a hard disk that could be replaced cheaply with a dime-sized SDHC chip with a resultant acceleration.

I think, though, that the Chrome OS-class machine as described by Google is useless if it can connect only to some commercial data center to run web apps. It must also have software for controlling your own desktop (in your case, your netbook) sitting at home in order to be a useful "second computer". Microsoft Azure or Google Apps for which you pay some monthly fee just won't do at all for a "primary computer", sorry.

Intel Giveth and Microsoft Taketh Away

The fact that very old machines with minimal CPU speeds and memory worked doesn't mean much. The first Windows machine I used at work was 12MHz and , I believe, 512KB and my experience is that that my pointing, clicking, and waiting are not greatly different from the modern ~2GHz, >2GB machines I use now.

I'm sure that if you tried to put Vista (or even XP) on a dusty old machine from 1985, it a) would not even work, and b) even if it did, it would be glacially slow.

I, for one, have had it with an OS that goes comatose for 10s of seconds while Process Explorer reports that 80%, 90%, or even more of the CPU is busy doing "System Idle Processes" whatever that is.

I just ordered a new laptop and as soon as it arrives, I intend to load Ubuntu and VMware on it and convert the Windows 7 that it comes with to a virtual machine.

So, I am cheering on Google (and any other non-MS OS developers) who might provide a better alternative.

Chrome OS hopefully delivers

Should be good for the Netbook market. For people whining about it being internet access.. hmm.. do we still live in 1990? Last time I checked it was 2009 and most of us have Web. Besides.. isn't what what Netbooks were made for? Access to the internet for e-mail and such.

2002?

Windows XP was released to retail channels in October 2001, which means it was designed earlier that year and part of the prior year.