Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


IT Blogwatch's picture
IT Blogwatch

A Daily Digest of IT Blogs from Richi Jennings

100 Mbps 4G LTE: Europe mocks U.S. slow progress

TeliaSonera users in Sweden and Norway are now enjoying 100 Mbps 4G mobile data with the latest LTE deployments. Looks more and more like WiMax has been sidelined. In IT Blogwatch, bloggers börk.börk.börk.

By Richi Jennings. December 15, 2009.

Your humble blogwatcher selected these bloggy morsels for your enjoyment. Not to mention if Star Wars characters used Facebook...
 
 
Mikael Ricknäs repörts:

TeliaSonera has launched the world's first commercial LTE (Long-Term Evolution) networks, in the central parts of Stockholm [Sweden] and Oslo [Norway]. ... Normal download speeds are expected be between 20 Mbps ... and 80 Mbps.
...
Recently, U.S. operator Verizon said its LTE network will deliver speeds between 5 Mbps and 12 Mbps. ... LTE is expected to be the next major standard in mobile broadband technology, and carriers have begun to convert their networks. Up to another 17 LTE networks are anticipated to be in service by the end of 2010 in the U.S., Canada, Japan, Norway, South Korea, South Africa, Sweden, Armenia and Finland.more


Bill Ray comes to bury WiMax, not to praise it:

The operator is pushing Long Term Evolution as offering ten times the speed of 3G ... at 2.6GHz, and making synonyms of LTE and 4G - as though WiMAX had never existed. ... WiMAX struggles to provide 6Mb/sec, despite officially being a 4G technology.
...
The power of LTE lies in its flexibility which allows it to operate at hugely variable speeds and frequencies. LTE isn't just intended to extend 3G capabilities, but to replace every radio standard used in mobile telephony.more


Jeff Bertolucci helps dig its grave:

Wireless service provider Clearwire is currently building the first national 4G network in the U.S. Using WiMax technology, Clearwire offers broadband speeds of 4Mbps to 6Mbps--relatively poky compared to TeliaSonera's 100Mbps offering.
...
And Comcast, using the Clearwire network, is offering WiMax 4G service in Portland, Oregon. The Comcast High-Speed 2go service maxes out at 4Mbps.more


Where's the kit coming from, Om Malik?

The carrier also has a license to roll out an LTE network in Finland. ... It’s using Ericsson and Huawei’s gear for this network, while Samsung is providing the LTE modem dongles. The network in Oslo offers maximum speeds of up to 100Mbps, according to Huawei.
...
We should start to hear about more LTE rollouts this year, including some kind of news announcement from Verizon Wireless, which is one of the more aggressive LTE backers in the world. In addition to Verizon, MetroPCS has plans to roll out an LTE network as well.more


Sarah Reedy reads the significance of the rollout:

TeliaSonera’s deployment is not a huge launch, covering less than half a million people, but a significant milestone for LTE nonetheless. The Swedish operator was able to turn on the network ahead of its initially scheduled 2010 date.
 
Meanwhile in the US, Verizon Wireless has plans to launch its first LTE market in the latter half of next year and then ramp-up quickly to a 30 markets, 100-million-pop footprint covering the largest cities in the US. AT&T is holding back even longer with plans for a 2011 deployment, choosing to wait until more devices are available.more


Erick Schonfeld grumbles, and resorts to the ob. IKEA joke:

The Scandinavians get everything first when it comes to mobile, except the iPhone. ... TeliaSonera says it will roll out the 4G service to 25 cities in Sweden and Norway in 2010. But you know how these things go. The full rollout may take longer because they are still trying to follow the instructions on how to put it together. They are pretty sure they are missing some bolts.
...
For the rest of us, the wait will be even longer. Mobile carriers in the U.S. are struggling under the weight of soaring Web phone data usage. Their 3G networks can hardly keep up (cough, AT&T). ... I suggest you move to Stockholm.more


So what's your take?
Get involved: leave a comment.

 
 
And finally...

 

Richi Jennings, your humble blogwatcher   Richi Jennings is an independent analyst/consultant, specializing in blogging, email, and security. A cross-functional IT geek since 1985, he is also an analyst at Ferris Research. You can follow him as @richi on Twitter, or richij on FriendFeed, pretend to be richij's friend on Facebook, or just use good old email: itblogwatch@richij.com.

 
 
Don't miss out on IT Blogwatch:

What People Are Saying

bandwidth

I just read your article on LTE/4g and wanted to give a little insight on the download speed numbers

Verizon's 5-12mbps speed are actually up to burst rates and are higher than the actual rated bandwidth, plus it doesn't exisit yet so it doesn't matter and is not being made to be an all IP flat internet network, it is just doing some thing to their legacy 3g phone network. this is the reason why companies like google and intel have invested else where

TeliaSonera in Norway's 100 mbps is actually per base station so if they want to off 20mbps service their tower would be full with 5 customers, so as they add capacity it will be impossible. Most 3g towers are a lot worse and only offer 1.5-54 mbpa per tower so if you have a couple hundred users in an area it can be a problem.
Their claim of being the first 4g company in the world seems way off base ans their have been a ton of them for a couple years now

As far as Clearwire I don't know about the U.S. but i use their Wimax in Malaga Spain and it has un-cappen mbps, the plan is rated at 6mps and usually runs around 7mbps during busy times and goes double that early in the morning. Might not be fast enough for everyone but I get a portable home ethernet modem and moblie usb laptop card for $50 a monht no contract and price locked in for life which seems like a better deal than $80 some in Norway. Plus apparently my card will work in Clearwire's other european cities and cities in the US too which is exciting as I am moving back to Chicago soon and just keep what I have plus on there website they seem to be hiring sales reps for almost every big city in the states

Geography Helps

If all of the U.S. population were packed like sardines into tiny spaces as is much of Europe, then deploying high speed anything would be a whole lot simpler.

Give the U.S.'s much lower overall population density, with more than twice the land area and less than half the population, cellular service requires a much larger deployment of towers and equipment to service the same number of people as in Europe. The U.S. has one-quarter the population density of Europe, and comparably requires 4 times the equipment to service the same population. Simply as a matter of logistics, there will always be areas of the U.S. that will likely never get DSL service or decent cellular coverage. And the cost of the available coverage will always be higher because of the higher costs for providing that coverage. Pile on top of that the nearly immediate obsolescence of newly deployed technologies, there is almost no return on investment for carriers on equipment that is only a year or two old that needs to be replaced to roll out the next latest technology.

Perhapse if the U.S. had over 1.2 billion people to service and were paying for service, then we'd likely have as good a coverage, for as cheap a price, and with as good technology as Europe now enjoys. Frankly, I'll live with and enjoy spotty connectivity and slower cell phone browsing speeds not to have to deal with arm-pit deep population overcrowding.

Geography Helps

Same old explanation if that is true how do you explain that major cities like New York have such bad coverage with AT&T and other carriers have similar terrible coverage in so many mid and large markets?

Just admit it I know it's not easy but US is on the verge of becoming a third rate country and not just in telecommunications.

According to WolframAlpha,

According to WolframAlpha, the US has a higher population density than Sweden: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=population+density+sweden+usa

I can assure you we are not overcrowded, still enjoying our nice communications infrastructure though.

Bork, Bork?

My how amusing Americans seem to think "bork, bork" is. I guess that's because you're all muppets, hehe ;)
Hey Richi, the letters ö and ø are NOT synonymous with the English "o". They actually represent different sounds and meanings than simple o's, I don't expect you to get it, but there, now you know.
The word "nørd" sounds exactly like the English word...

Nej. Jag är inte Amerikanska. Börk börk börk!

Hey! Watch who you're calling an American.

While my Swedish is rusty-to-the-point-of-non-existence, I speak several other European languages and do have a fair grasp of diacritics. But, hey, thanks for assuming I'm an ignoramus.

If you've ever watched the Muppets, you'd understand why I spelled it "börk". Surely spelling it with an "o" would be quite wrong: wouldn't that sound more like "book"?

Oh, and since when did modern Swedish use "ø"? Or was the aforementioned Muppet actually the Norwegian Chef? ;-)