Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Preston Gralla's picture
Preston Gralla

Seeing Through Windows

Acer and Intel: Crippled Windows 7 netbooks won't sell

The crippled version of Windows 7 that will ship with some netbooks may be a non-starter --- partners Acer and Intel have both said they don't believe that netbooks equipped that way will sell.

As I blogged yesterday, Microsoft has said that it will limit to three the number of applications people can run simultaneously on many Windows 7-equipped netbooks --- those that run the Windows 7 Starter edition.

Microsoft gets less money for Windows on netbooks than it does on laptops or desktop PCs --- $15 for netbooks versus $50 to $60 for laptops and desktops, by some accounts. So the idea is that if someone wants a full version of Windows 7 that can run more than three applications simultaneously, they'll have to pay extra for it.

Most likely, that will only ensure that Linux laptops will begin selling in big numbers again, and that people will also forgo Windows 7 netbooks for Windows XP ones, which will only further hurt Microsoft.

I'm not alone in thinking that. Two of Microsoft's biggest partners --- Acer and Intel --- think the same thing. The Wall Street Journal interviewed Sumit Agnihotry, a vice president of product marketing at Acer. Here's what the newspaper had to say about Agnihotry's thoughts:

[Agnihotry] wouldn't say whether Acer plans to use the Windows 7 Starter version. But he said that being able to run just three applications -- and the requirement that customers pay extra for a higher-end version -- could be a tough sell, since Windows XP has no such limits.

Acer expects to sell models at different price increments, Mr. Agnihotry said, noting that customers are willing to pay more for features beyond what XP offers. Acer is "very sensitive about adding new cost" since netbooks' greatest attraction is their low price, he said.

In other words, people aren't going to be likely to want to spend extra for the full version of Windows 7, and and Acer might not even be willing to put it on its netbooks.

Similarly, Intel isn't convinced that putting Windows 7 Starter edition on nebooks is a good idea. The newpaper notes:

Intel Corp., a longtime Microsoft ally whose Atom microprocessor powers most netbooks, has also voiced some skepticism about Microsoft's Windows 7 plans. Intel Chief Executive Paul Otellini said at an investor conference in February that Microsoft's plan to convince consumers to upgrade from the Starter version "is going to be tough for a bunch of reasons."

If even Acer and Intel, two of Microsoft's most important partners, aren't convinced that Microsoft is doing the right thing, it's time for Microsoft to re-think its plans.

 

What People Are Saying

Acer Netbook - A user's comment on durability

This is a slightly different comment. I'm an Acer Netbook owner, more of a business user and just took it for a trip to the Midwest. Within a few days of driving, the screen had been broken despite my efforts to find and buy a good case for it. I would have thought these smaller devices would have been designed for more rugged environments but they are not. I liked the size and lighter weight from a regular laptop which I've owned for about 5 years (and with no damage to the screen). Now I'm facing a significant cost in non-insured repair. Some thoughts. Someone should have brought a hard traveling case to market as a protection. My uses are GPS, minor Word and Excel docs and Internet email use. I haven't yet checked with Pelican or Halliburton. Another alternative - one I'm pursuing - is to buy two hard nylon sheets and place them on both sides sandwiched with extra foam. My existing case had at least a half inch of foam but didn't resist points of pressure. I notice some of the other netbooks seem to have a more flexible screen (eg., Sony at about $2500.00. Perhaps they are more rugged. Except for the lack of a good keyboard (just locate the keys like an ergonomic board does; they don't have to be much larger) I don't have more complaints at present. Would I buy this product again? Probably not. I'd wait for better cases and tougher designs.

D A

Gosh, I can't wait. A

Gosh, I can't wait. A crippled notebook with a third rate OS. Where do I sign up?

It will sell

It may be crippled but at least its windows. Linux on net books may be fully functional and free, too bad most normal people dont want to use it because its not windows. People will have to pay for what they want in the end, the free option is a non-starter for most.

"Crippled" Windows 7

We need more Gates-ness and less Balmer-ness. Attempting to sell a "crippled" version of Windows 7 is a huge marketing mistake. It can only result in bad advertising every time it is discussed and every time the user gets a message saying "Sorry, you can not start another application. This version of Windows 7 only allows three simultaneous applications to run."

The much smarter move, is to ensure that Windows 7 is unquestionably the right OS for netbooks, along with all other machines of this size and larger. To do this, Microsoft should sell cheaply - as cheaply for netbooks as the currently proffered limited process version. The right way to do this IMO, is to make a low end version of windows that will only run without warnings if 1GB or less memory is installed.

No MS for me thank you.

Netbooks being offers with more Memory, bigger hard disks, larger screens, MS OS and bigger pricetags, oh wait thats a laptop not a netbook!

give me 1 GB(or less!) an 8GB SSD and a screen that I can read outside, let me put my own OS on it(no bundled OS to inflate your market share survey) for under $200.00 thats a Netbook!

The people who say windows 7 runs fine on their netbook own underpowered laptops not netbooks.

Anyway netbooks are a niche item for Linux users, if you blow them up into Windows laptops who cares? They arn't netbooks anymore.

I was recently looking for a netbook, Most of them now ship with XP, I told newegg I would pay $10.00 more if they didn't put XP on it. I don't want to be added to the MS FUD about netbook users actually using Windows!

I agree with everything you

I agree with everything you said, execpt for the comment on "netbooks are a niche item for Linux users"... I couldn't disagree more. While they may have started out as a niche item back in 2007 when Asus introduced the concept of a Netbook, they have become more and more popular among non-niche users (i.e. every day people who want something that is actually portable, won't leave a hole in their pocket or lap...excuse the pun), and subsequently every major PC manufacturer now has their own brand of "Netbook". Than again, I am responding to a comment that was posted in April, so maybe your view has changed.

BTW, I own an Asus Eee PC, and I threw a copy of Windows 7 just for kicks.. NOTE: I am normally a vehement advocate for Linux (Ubuntu), but it was a while since I dabled in anthing MS related, so I gave it a true. I gotta admit, that after a 2GB upgrade, I am pleasantly surprised.

Cheers

Windows 7

It is a shame that there are limited options in operating system offered. It is being taken for granted that it will be Win 7. For all the years I have been using computers since the card readers, I believe the lack of option makes up for bad products and pricing issues.
This is probably the best time for any processor maker to open up to new options..
No wonder there are so many antitrust suits aginst MS. It is bad that they are taking that rapp on their own, when the 5K lb. Gorilla is dangling the banana on the other side.
The funny thing about all these is that I used to turn an apple computer on at school because I could not afford one at home, and it did not take much time to boot up. The more I use PC's associated with windows, it seems that the more time I spend waiting for the PC's to boot up.
One time Steve Jobs said that Microsoft put out a third class product. At the time it seemed so bold and may be arrogant, but now after a few years and lots of proofs (Windows Vista) he must have had his crystal ball with him, because he was right on the money.
And we the users keep waiting for a break through a solution a simple approach and a standard method of doing things. One of the most ironic point of Windows Vista is that in Spanish Vista means Sight. So, having window sight to the ocean is not a bad idea; however, in the software context what a set back.
JS

NO WIDNOWS UBUNTU?

ADN I BEEEN TRYVING TO BOOS MAN JIM THE BOSS TO BUY ME A NEEW EEE PC NETBROK, BUT SNINCE IT WONT HAVE WIDOWS UBNUNTU 7 ON IT, HE NOT BYUING IT NOW.

No words describe the

No words describe the insanity peppers of your submission. Windows Ubuntu 7 huh?

Check out Shark Tank to get

Check out Shark Tank to get a better idea behind his humor-be sure to check out Jim The Boss's posts, and you'll understand.