Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Seth Weintraub's picture
Seth Weintraub

Apple versus Google

Apple to pioneer use of Silver-Zinc battery technology?

I've heard rumors that Apple is going to make some radical changes to the 17-inch MacBook Pro's battery configuration. My understanding is that the new unibody 17-inch laptop will last as much as 50% longer on a single charge as the current 17-inch laptop. Additionally, Apple is building in the battery like it does on the MacBook Air, iPods and iPhone instead of making it removable like current MacBook Pros.

How does Apple plan on doing this both from a technology perspective and a public relations perspective? What technology will they use? Super capacitors or fuel cells? Maybe even carbon nano tube based cells? Not yet.

My guess is that Apple is going to move from Lithiom-ion batteries to Silver-Zinc models.

Silver Zinc batteries from a California company called ZPower fit the bill pretty well. According to their FAQ:

ZPower has partnered with one of the top global manufacturers of notebook computers to roll out a laptop with a silver-zinc battery option in early 2009 [Macworld-ish?]. The notebook will have the capability to work with either silver-zinc or lithium-ion batteries (i.e. it will be dual chemistry enabled). ZPower is the first company to launch a rechargeable, silver-zinc battery in the mobile electronics market.

Secret top tier notebook manufacturer? Who likes to keep secrets?

The case doesn't stop there. To put a battery inside the laptop a few concerns will have to be addressed. First it will have to be safe. ZPower says their batteries are much safer than Lithium:

The ZPower battery contains no lithium and is inherently safe. ZPower batteries are not subject to recent FAA air travel restrictions now placed on lithium-ion batteries.

Why are ZPower batteries safer?

  • ZPower batteries offer an intrinsically safe, lithium-free, water-based chemistry.
  • ZPower batteries have no thermal runaway and are not flammable
  • ZPower batteries have passed wide range of safety tests including:
    • Heating
    • Temperature Cycling
    • Short Circuit
    • Abnormal Charge (overcharge)
    • Forced Discharge (reverse charge)
    • Impact
    • Crush
    • Drop
    • Nail Penetration
  • ZPower batteries are not restricted by Li-ion battery regulations for in-flight use.

Silver-Zinc isn't a new, untested technology either. It has been used by NASA and Aircraft industries for years.

It was the power source in all of the Apollo spacecraft: the Saturn launch vehicles, command module re-entry batteries, the lunar module and the lunar rover. (The Apollo Service Module used fuel cells as a primary power source.)

Also, to have an entirely internal battery, they'd need to be able to take many more charges than the current Lithium batteries which putter out in one to three years. I've had to replace my MacBook Pro Battery after two years of use because the charge would only last a few minutes. Luckily, Silver-Zinc starts to degrade in charge only after five years of use. Nice!

They also charge faster - at least in the area that matters most:

A laptop computer battery using ZPower cells can charge in 5 hours. The ZPower battery charges at a constant rate throughout the complete charge cycle. In contrast, lithium-ion batteries decelerate to a slower rate towards the last 20-30% of a charge cycle. As a result, ZPower batteries charge faster than lithium-ion batteries from 70% to 100% --which is where most consumers focus their charging activity.

ZPower also fits into Apple's Green initiatives:

  • ZPower was awarded the AlwaysOn GoingGreen 100 Award in 2007 for energy storage. The company was honored because 95% of the key elements in ZPower batteries can be recycled and reused. ZPower is also taking a leading role in providing financial incentives to consumers who recycle.
  • The primary materials of ZPower batteries (i.e. silver and zinc) are fully recyclable. That means that the materials derived from recycling process are of the same quality as the materials that went into the initial creation of the battery. This reduces the need to mine for new materials and minimizes the removal of silver and zinc from the earth’s crust.
  • In contrast, the primary elements of traditional lithium-ion batteries are downcycled and cannot be reused. The downcycling process reduces the original battery into raw materials of lower quality which can’t be reused for battery production. Additional lithium must be obtained before another battery can be produced.
  • The silver recycling process already exists. Refiners perfected the processes over centuries for jewelry, tableware, photographic film, and electronics. Additionally, silver obtained from scrap makes up over 30% of the silver that is needed each year to satisfy world demand.
  • ZPower is the first rechargeable battery company in the portable electronic segment to offer financial incentives to consumers who recycle. ZPower will make it easy for consumers to return their used batteries to ZPower in exchange for a credit towards the purchase of a new silver-zinc battery. This innovative approach to battery recycling for mobile electronics will be introduced in 2009 when ZPower batteries are launched with a leading notebook computer manufacturer.

Silver-Zinc batteries also have a higher power density by a factor of two. You can get twice the storage capacity in the same space or the same storage in half the space. Apple would probably split the difference, getting more power out of a smaller-sized battery.

The downside is that these batteries cost much more than Lithium Ion to make. As part of the most expensive Apple laptop however, that cost could be easier to absorb, and with all of the listed benefits, easily justified. As production is ramped up, the economics of scale will make them more reasonably priced.

The new battery technology could also be the reason that Apple had to wait on the release of the 17-inch Unibody MacBook Pro. ZPower had originally expected to release its technology in 2008 but it just slipped to early 2009 for unknown technical reasons.

We have two more days until we find out. Don't forget to check my Macworld liveblog here.

Related news & opinion

What People Are Saying

Power density factor is NOT 2.0x

Seth,
You missed ZPower's own web page that says that the same volume of battery results in 30% greater energy storage than Lithium-Ion. That's a power density ratio of 1.3 (not 2.0) over Li-Ion.

Great article. Just one

Great article.

Just one note, the company said they made an agreement with a large laptop producer. At the same time Sony is expected to launch a new expensive "Netbook" in CES.
The slogan on their website says "You will change your look to laptops forever".

So could it be the new Sony Vaio that will be loaded with Zinc, not the MBP?

At the same time i wish they get the same batteries to 13-in Macbooks :) iWant

Interesting

I read about Zpower a couple of months ago after engadget reported on Energiser reporting on releasing a new battery technology at CES which is also rumoured to be silver zinc (for standard size rechargeable batteries).

I think one of the comments about 15's already being dual chemistry may well be true as in the UK nearly all the major retail chains have sold out of Unibody style Mac's and when i went into an Apple store last week to get an MBP the purple shirt told me to wait till MacWorld with a knowing wink!

"knowing wink"

That "knowing wink" was really just an "I think I know something but I just read MacRumors.com wink". Apple retail employees - not even managers or geniuses - don't get advance information about new products.

I came to the same conclusion

As soon as I heard the non-removable battery rumor, I went to Silver-Zinc.

The only thing you got wrong in your write up is the battery lifetime. Yes, the battery will last up to 5 years and has very low self-discharge, but the cycle life is currently unknown. Initially, Silver-Zinc batteries had very very short cycle counts (50-75 cycles to 80%). ZPower says they can get up to 200 cycles to 80%, but current Li-Ion batteries have a cycle count of 300 to 80%. Hardcore power users might be making yearly trips to their Apple store to have the battery replaced (though those same users are probably getting a new battery every 18 months with their Li-Ion battery).

But since you have to go to Apple to get the battery replaced anyways, Apple gets the old one and recycles the silver and zinc in the battery. They can essentially subsidize the price of the new battery with the recycled materials from the old one.

Later this year, this might become a "feature" of all the other Apple laptops, starting with the MacBook Air. I'd love a thinner, lighter MB with a little bit better battery life.

What about the 15"?

If the 17" is "dual-chemistry" and it was ready at the same time as the 15" but was only delayed because of the battery, then it makes sense that the 15" is also "dual-chemistry".

Apple may also announce a Silver-Zinc battery pack for the 15"!!!!

Great Article

Wonderful article! If Apple weren't considering this. I bet after reading your well researched work, they will consider it.

Hope to see this tech in lots of devices in the future.

that was the most enjoyable

that was the most enjoyable Rumor i've read in a long while,

thanks for that thought out blog.

great

If apple can pull off a 9 hour battery life then that's as good as having 2 batteries. Im a serious power user of the 17, i love this idea.

I'll get one...

If it has 6+ hours of real life usage, I'll get it. Sounds great.

The only issue I see is charging time - 5 hours to full charge is not something to write home about. Li batteries quick charge to about 80%, the rest takes longer - but that 80% is already pretty useful.

I replace my MBP battery every year, but that's in part because when the battery gets below 90% it only lasts 2 hours 30 and that's not enough. Currently I am on a 6 month old Li battery with 90% charge, just over 2:30 battery life, and 99 cycles. Yep, I _use_ the battery :)

I'll definitely get the 3 year AppleCare and then expect Apple to replace the ZPower battery whenever it goes below 80%.... call me sceptical but I think that will happen more than once.