Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Barbara Krasnoff's picture
Barbara Krasnoff

The Interesting Bits ... and Bytes

Facebook backs down -- again.

Sometimes I wonder what's on Mark Zuckerberg's calendar. Along with notes for birthdays and holidays, I'm beginning to suspect he has an early February reminder that goes something like, "Make draconian change. Anger users. Back down."

If you've been following the recent tsunami among Facebook users, you know about the recently discovered change in the service's Terms of Service (ToS), in which Facebook apparently claimed ownership of everything you uploaded to the service forever, even after you closed the account. Once it was revealed by The Consumerist, the population of Facebook exploded. A group was immediately formed. People declared their intention to immediately delete all their photos or other copyrightable work, or to leave Facebook completely. Non-Facebook members looked on smugly. The Web simmered.

At first, Facebook issued the usual, "No, you can trust us. We're good guys," statements that most users treated with all the respect statements like that deserve. In a time when companies are bought, sold, and traded like baseball cards, you can't count simply on the goodwill of the current owners -- especially when you have a ToS that says otherwise.

Last night, Zuckerberg announced in a blog entry that Facebook is going to "return to our previous terms of use while we resolve the issues that people have raised." He continues to explain that the Facebook crew does plan to change the ToS within a few weeks and, to his credit, asserts that Facebook users "will have a lot of input in crafting these terms."

I'm glad that Facebook is taking these steps. Obviously, Zuckerberg and the rest of the Facebook staff are willing to change their minds if a move turns out to be wrong (or, at least, enormously unpopular).

But it's interesting to note that this is not the first time Facebook has had to react to member anger. Almost exactly a year ago, in February, 2008, Facebook faced demands from several thousand users that they be allowed to permanently delete their accounts and all content associated with it.

Sound vaguely familiar? It's almost as if Zuckerberg (or Facebook's legal team) has an annual appointment to try to keep -- and possibly use -- as much member content as possible, whether or not the members are still part of the service. 

So here's some advice for Facebook: Next year, if you start getting the February doldrums, try throwing a party, or take a trip, or maybe buy yourself a new company or two. Just leave the users -- and their content -- alone. It's really not worth the fuss.

What People Are Saying

But they have not backtracked completely!

Keep in mind that even if you have to backtrack a little each time, you can still making headway toward your goal. And Facebook's goal is obviously to find a way to make lots of money from all that personal info stored at Facebook. And they will. When you go on Facebook, everything you put there is now owned by Facebook. They can say whatever they want to you but behind your back, guess what they are doing with all that data?

Trust me

It's never a good sign when a company (or person) resorts to simply saying "Trust me" on a regular basis. That's what con artists do for a living.

And even if I did trust Z and his current company, how do I know I can trust the folks he'll sell that company to, or the next person who runs it?

I agree -- just too many darned pleas followed by more and more controversy.

Scrabulous, anyone?

Social networking is CRAP!!

All this social networking is nothing but a bunch of crap. It's a major invasioin of people's privacy on the part of the companies (Facebook, MySpace, etc) and the members that post information. I personally do not want any picture or information about me or any of my family posted anywhere without my knowledge. I also believe that social networking is nothing but a huge distraction for a lot of people in their day to day jobs. I'll leave this rant as proof positive and use myself as an example!! We need to get back to basics folks. The party's over!! Ya know the old saying work hard play hard? Well the last 20-15 years we've been doin a lot of playin, but not much workin!

Is that you Mike?

Is that you Mike?

Typo

I meant the last 10-15 years.