Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Preston Gralla's picture
Preston Gralla

Seeing Through Windows

Four things Mac OS X can learn from Windows 7

Microsoft has been accused over the years of stealing many of the Mac's features for Windows. But Windows 7 shows that there are things that Apple can learn from Microsoft. Here are four things that Mac OS X can learn from Windows 7.

Windows 7 taskbar

Start off with the new taskbar. Yes, I know that the Windows 7 taskbar has been modeled on the Mac OS X Dock, but Microsoft does it one better. Both the Dock and the Windows 7 taskbar do double duty as task switchers and program launchers. But the Windows 7 taskbar does it better, particularly as a task switcher. When you're running a program, and it's got multiple windows open, you see an indication of how many windows are open. By hovering over the program's icon, you can see thumbnails of every program running. It's simply better than the Dock.

Jump lists

Related to the new taskbar is the new jump list feature. A jump list is a list of actions or items associated with a particular application. To see a jump list for any application, right-click its icon in the taskbar or in the Most Recently Used Application list on the Start menu. Each jump list's actions or items varies according to the program, but generally you'll see a history list of recently opened files, as well as ways to customize how the application works, such as pinning it to the taskbar. When you right-click an icon in the Mac OS X Dock, you also get a list of items, but they don't include recently used files. Mac OS X should learn from Window 7 and add that feature.

Insane Desktop backgrounds

The choice of Windows 7 Desktop backgrounds is as strange and bizarrely entertaining group of artwork as you'll come across on a PC. They combine Sergeant Pepper-style psychedelics with Japanese anime, with a healthy dose of Hieronymus Bosch grotesques thrown in. Microsoft, for once, seems to have gone wild and crazy.

In the Mac OS X background, by way of contrast, Apple seems to have discovered its inner nerd. Beach, forest, nature, abstract art...yes, it's all there, and all exceedingly dull. I have no doubt there are plenty of artists at Apple waiting to strut their stuff. Apple should turn them loose.

Network Center

The Windows Network Center isn't new to Windows 7 --- it's been around since Vista. But it was one of the best things about Vista, and remains one of the best things about Windows. It brings together every setting and option you can imagine about networking -- much superior to the Internet & Network section of Mac OS X's System Preferences. And the Network Map, which shows a live, graphical map of your network, is great as well. Apple should steal it.

What People Are Saying

Uneducated Bias Comparison

I read this article twice in hopes of perhaps seeing the viewpoint. Unfortunately, reading it the 2nd time only made me feel stronger about how poorly the article is written. The research is both imaginary and daft.

Comparing the Taskbar to the Dock is apples and oranges. Mac has a taskbar up top called a Menubar. The Dock serves more as a shortcut launcher and it has both MORE customizable options than the Windows taskbar. Check out Dock Library, the dock can be customized beautifully. As for features -- Thumbnails? The icon was a thumbnail before it was opened. Why would one need to know what the file they are working on looks like after it's already been opened. It's opened. Just look at it.

Just because the dock doesn't say how many windows are open at once doesn't make it inferior. This is, and I'll use your word, "Simply" unneeded in Mac OS X. With the flick of the mousepad, all open windows can be viewed instantly in Expose. That's why it was invented. Did we already forget Apple's old slogan? "Think Different." It's not better or worse, it's different. If anything, it's plenty adequate.

Jump Lists -- a fancy term for menu options. Ahhhh yes, another Windows user failing to understand how the Mac OS works. These may be very handy on Windows because Windows is already too difficult to work with. However, adding features like this to an already simple OS is moot. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.

Insane backgrounds? Why is it every time there's a debate about Windows vs. Mac (as if anyone really cares), someone that uses Windows brings up the brilliance of wallpapers? Is wallpaper the most phenomenal discovery ever? The best thing since sliced bread? Can computers not function without them? Go to any site such as Wincustomize.com, or even better, Interfacelift.com. You can download all the high quality FREE wallpaper you want. As for Mac -- picking and choosing the poor examples of wallpaper doesn't make you sound like an expert... it makes you sound snooty. Try researching the lot, first. Snow Leopard has a gorgeous variety of Monet paintings to choose from. Ahhhhhh yes, but Monet wasn't anyone of visual artistic notoriety. Certainly not.

I haven't once found a website that doesn't debate network genius between Mac and Windows. All in all, the Windows networking is just too complex. I'll keep this example simple. I have a hidden network in my home. Wifi. No password. Simply... invisible. When I connect, I simply click on the router icon in the taskbar. Then I select "join network" and type in my network name. Checking the "Remember this network" box flawlessly allows my computer to see the invisible network forever.

The other day... A friend came by with her Windows 7 setup laptop.

We had to jump through hoops to connect to this network. We found ourselves opening properties and various options just to find a simple way to add this new network in. It wasn't a first step, it was at the end of 6 or 7 steps. In the end, the connection worked after repeating one method of connection 3 times without doing anything different. The first 2 times it simply wouldn't connect. 3rd time is a charm, eh? I don't care what features or complex abilities Windows is capable of. I didn't appreciate spending 30min trying to get online where I could get on in seconds with my Mac.

Before I finish up, just a little observation I've noticed between Mac and PC users. Mac users, like myself, don't honestly care. We love our Macs. We don't write "Why Mac is better than PC" articles. We don't really get upset when someone puts down our Macs. We just say, "Okay. Well, I love my Mac. Enjoy." (I understand the irony of saying all of this in a nearly counter-acting writeup myself.)

PC users respond to criticism or dislikes with, "No way!!! Mac sucks!! What's wrong with Windows??? NOTHING!!!" Overall... anger. Where does this pent up aggression come from? I know, I know! It comes from... years of dealing with terrible operating systems. If you love your PC, then love your PC. Don't try to change Macs into PCs. We're not willing to become Bill Gates' lab rats. We like what we have. We will never change.

*** FACT ***

Many people are switching from PC to Mac. Very few long time Mac users, if any, are switching to PC. Apple offers free transfer from your old PC to your new Mac upon purchase. No PC company offers the the same vice versa. Curious, isn't it?

thanks

Thanks for sharing these info with us! I was reading something similar on youtube website that i was researching. I will be sure to look around more. thanks...

Desktop Backgrounds/Wallpaper?

You found 4 things! Bravo! One of them is desktop backgrounds? Come on.

Also didn't you catch Snow Leopards new dock features?

You are stupid

LOL DOCK FEATURES?
Go shove yourself. Dock features? I'm still laughing. Four stupid things are better then one even more stupid comment. Dock features? HAHAHA
Windows has better customizable docks then Apple has. Dock features...lol.

It's really 3 things Apple can learn from MS

Since the windows backgrounds you can find online. Not really sure why this point is here? And how many things can MS learn from Apple? Oh, nevermind they already stole all of those ideas already.

5th and most important:

5th and most important: security

osx was the most unsecure os in the world in 2008 (according to ibm x-force). Windows tops even the linux kernel.

Are you retarded?

Apple has the MOST advanced security system in the world. Honestly? In 4 years, there has only been one apple virus. And, 2 days later, there was an update to get rid of it.

Stupid people.

Windows 7 has high

Windows 7 has high performance over vista and even XP. It's user friendly and I encountered no crashes or compatibility issues.

It supports a wide range of devices and PC is THE choice for gaming. Economically speaking a PC is generally cheaper than a Mac.

I installed Windows 7 RC1 on both my desktop and my IBM T60 with 512mb RAM. I'm a PC and I will definitely buy Windows 7 when it comes out this summer.

That's all Windows has on OSX?!

Those 4 meaningless points are pretty pathetic!! let's talk stability, functionality, usability...how about the real details and not useless dribble!

Windows heads will always be windows heads ie. as useless as the OS!

Microshaft hasn't got anything right in +20 years since IBM sold them their first OS, lets not forget it was IBMs core code that made Microsoft. IBM Dos it originated as. What would ever make you Microsoft sheep believe that all of a sudden the coders got it right this time around??! LMAO

Bahhhhh - Sheep!

Don't ever compare Mac OS, a real OS to that crap they call an OS, Windoze! when Windoze becomes as stable, functional, and usable as Mac OS always has, and its users and techs actually know how to use a computer, then and only then can you even try to come out with a shot back at Apple. and these 4 petty terms aren't a shot, they only describe how pathetic you people are.

Unix/Linux...Feel the power!!!

I'm only going to counter two things...

1--If your beloved OSX is so stable, then WHY is there an option to "Force Quit"??? Please do tell....

2--Under your "WONDERFUL" Linux, why must a user jerk around at the command prompt (and root, to boot!) to install an RPM package? I was playing around with Fedora 10, and trying to get Adobe's Reader installed was a freakin' nightmare! And, you Linux bois have your nose so far up in the air, heaven forbid a noob ask politely on a forum how to do this.

BTW, Junior, I go back to the days of DOS and assembly language, so don't think I don't know my way around a text interface. But, your average user will have NO clue what to do, and I can only imagine the scorn and disdain that such "experts" like yourself will be happy to heap upon them.