Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Preston Gralla's picture
Preston Gralla

Seeing Through Windows

Google Voice: Press "1" to invade your privacy

Lost in all the hooplah about the release of Google Voice is this disturbing fact: The service will give Google enormous amounts of information about the intimate details of your everyday life, including recordings of your voice mail and possibly your phone calls. Combined with what Google already knows about you, it could mean your privacy is at an end.

Google Voice, by all accounts, may be the best tool ever for managing your telephone communications. It routes all of your calls through a single number, and can then ring all of your phones simultaneously. You can manage your voice mail with it, including getting free transcripts of your calls. It includes free voice conferencing, inexpensive overseas calls, and plenty more. You'll also be able to record and store your calls online.

But all that information about your calls will be routed through Google. Google will know everyone who called you and when they called. They'll have records of your voice mail, and because they offer free transcription, it means they'll have not just the voice, but text of your calls as well. They'll have recordings of your phone calls --- and I would expect them to offer transcriptions of them as well, which means they'll have the transcriptions as well as your calls.

Google Voice will be offered for free. Google, though, will certainly be looking for ways to make money from it. One of the most obvious ways is via targeted advertising, particularly because the company recently announced that it's going to figure out new ways to target ads based on your interests. It already does this with Gmail. So don't be surprised to see ad targeted based on who calls you.

Doing that means that Google will be mining data from your calls, possibly including what is being said on the calls themselves. It already does the equivalent of this in Gmail, looking for key words, and then displaying ads based on those words.

Privacy advocates are already worried. Marc Rotenberg, executive director of the Electronic Privacy Information Center, when interviewed by the New York Times, has this warning about the service: "In the privacy world, it is increased profiling and tracking of users without safeguards."

Google already has a profile about your interests and surfing habits. If you use Gmail, it examines the content of your mail as a way to target ads. With Google Voice, it will know who you're talking to, and when you're talking to them --- and will have records of your voice mail, and possibly recordings of your actual calls themselves.

Given that, will there anything about your personal life that Google won't know?

What's next: Google Bedroom? I don't even want to think about that one.

What People Are Saying

How is this any different

How is this any different than the phone company, who has had access to listen to your phone calls since phones existed, has had access to your voicemail since voicemail existed, and likely sells your phone number to marketing companies to make a quick buck?

Honestly? I'd rather Google have access than anyone else - and it's not a trust issue as much as it's an issue of it not really mattering, and my thinking that the Google folks are more interested in making legitimate money rather than screwing their userbase.

I think since computers have

I think since computers have been invented and hooked up to the telephone line our privacy has no longer been our privacy.

People gleen whatever they want from us, even supermarkets use face recognition and eye scanning software now, it's pretty scary.

Your tinfoil hat is showing

You've obviously never seen the text transcription.... the only thing google knows about me is that my Mom calls and talks about "hissing that bun lady" secretly though she's asking to "visit this Sunday"

Wow, with that knowledge bestowed to Google, the Bun lady will know our plans to hiss at her... Damn foiled again.

Here's to hoping that Google isn't Alien for "I like to eat humans"

Your tinfoil hat is showing

You've obviously never seen the text transcription.... the only thing google knows about me is that my Mom calls and talks about "hissing that bun lady" secretly though she's asking to "visit this Sunday"

Wow, with that knowledge bestowed to Google, the Bun lady will know our plans to hiss at her... Damn foiled again.

Here's to hoping that Google isn't Alien for "I like to eat humans"

OH NO!!

You mean Google will actually display ads that are pertinent to myself?! NOOOO!!!! Shut up, man.

I think some users would be

I think some users would be upset to know that you can search Google and get links to user's voice mail messages. I listened to several of them and found a few with some very personal information between a professional and his life coach/business partner. The name and phone number of the caller is most often prominently displayed on the page. Check it out here:

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&safe=off&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla%3Aen-US%3Aofficial&hs=Vnl&tag=thebotnet.com&q=site%3Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com%2Fvoice%2Ffm%2F*&aq=f&oq=&aqi=

thanks for sharing Google

thanks for sharing
Google

That's a huge security hole.

That's a huge security hole. Have you reported it to Google?

Phone Companies

Don't phone companies have the ability to do all of the above? They could be doing the same thing, enforcing paranoia about a company not minding it's own business is a useless fear tactic. Google screens many things, not just key words in e-mail, it's the way their business operates, what's to say they care what it is? My point of view is that they clearly don't want to invade your privacy, simply conduct their business while providing extremely useful services at no charge. Maybe you could make an arrangement in the future, or use the credit system they have in place for international calls, to separate the service into the distinct ad free versions of the product, similar to how they offer a business option of Google Docs/Gmail, where they enforce the security of the servers, and privacy of their clients?

"Don't phone companies have

"Don't phone companies have the ability to do all of the above?"

No. Historically, they've needed a court order to wiretap (thank goodness).