Ads by TechWords
Subscribe to our e-mail newsletters
For more info on a specific newsletter, click the title. Details will be displayed in a new window.
Computerworld Daily News (First Look and Wrap-Up)
Computerworld Blogs Newsletter
The Weekly Top 10
More E-Mail Newsletters 
Mike Elgan's picture
Mike Elgan

The World Is My Office

Great gadget ruined by form factor

SANTA BARBARA, CALIF. -- Asus, the Taiwanese company that makes the popular Asus Eee PC, has come up with an absolutely wonderful idea ruined by its form factor. The idea is to combine portable wireless mouse with flash storage. Designers chose -- inexplicably -- to make the device shaped not like a mouse, for which ergonomics are everything, but like a memory stick, for which ergonomics are irrelevant.

The Asus MS71 storage mouse, unveiled today at CeBIT 2008, has some ingenious design elements. It looks more or less the size of a big pack of gum. One end is held in place by a magnet. You detach the small end, which holds the transmitter, from the body of the device, and plug it into your laptop's USB drive. When you want to charge the mouse, just snap it back together while the transmitter is still connected, and it charges.

Brilliant!

Unfortunately, nobody is going to buy the darn thing because it's a terrible mouse, too boxy to use. How hard would it have been to simply change the shape of the plastic to make it fit a human hand?

Asus, don't ship this product. Go back and re-design the housing to make it an ergonomic mouse, then ship it. If you do that, every mobile user is going to want one.

 

What People Are Saying

Rate this
Rated +32
524 Votes

Mike Elgan?

Why are Mike Elgan stories being dugg so profusely lately?

Rate this
Rated -53
473 Votes

Google's Interesting Items

Among other reasons, this article is showing up on Google's "Interesting Items" list based on user's web history. That's how I came across this page...a page I would have never come across by any other means.

I've noticed many of these Google suggested pages start to get a big increase in traffic once they appear. Images on photobucket get taken down in minutes, links to forum posts get closed, moved or deleted by moderators, etc.

Kind of an interesting thing to see happen. Sort of like a very small scale version of this on a large number of different sites / pages / files:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slashdot_effect

Rate this
Rated +29
491 Votes

Look at that hair!

Look at that hair!

Rate this
Rated +13
515 Votes

Mouse

The mouse is a infrared mouse, it is meant to waived like a wand. It is NOT meant to be used like a traditional mouse!

Rate this
Rated -39
595 Votes

T!TS OR GTFO

T!TS OR GTFO

Rate this
Rated +29
525 Votes

Microsoft already sells this

MS already sells a wireless laptop mouse w/ 1GB of storage in the receiver:
http://www.microsoft.com/hardware/mouseandkeyboard/productdetails.aspx?pid=098

Rate this
Rated +30
496 Votes

Or sell an optional ergonomic cover

Sell a snap on (possibly collapsible) mouse shaped piece of plastic that people who don't like the form factor can attach, and make it cheap as hell. (It had better be, it's just a molded piece of plastic.) Put a coupon in the box that lets me order one for $1 plus shipping, and sell them on the Asus website for $3 each plus shipping, or if it's not too late, throw one in the box and give it to me for free. (Hell, sell them in funky decorative colors or whatever.)

Rate this
Rated +35
507 Votes

What makes this gadget great

What makes this gadget great is the form factor.
If you want a bigger portable wireless mouse, there are already several in the market. This one is not small by mistake.

Rate this
Rated -21
527 Votes

Get your own damn picture

Get your own damn picture instead of a link... Picture's no longer available.

Rate this
Rated +61
505 Votes

I like it really, the whole

I like it really, the whole reason I got an Asus EEE is because it's so easy to put it in my bag and forget about it until I need it. Unlike my normal laptop which will give me a sore neck and shoulders before the day is over lugging it around.

In a similar vein, I wouldn't want a fullsize or even a mini-size mouse with my EEE either, but a little usb stick that just happens to be a little more convenient than the tiny trackpad...perfect!