Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Mark Everett Hall's picture
Mark Everett Hall

Sanity as a Service

Hey, Stranger: Social media meets B2B

There's a new Web site dedicated to introduce B2B marketers to the joys of social media and it's called, in a no-nonsense B2B style, Social Media B2B. I'm certain some companies can strengthen their ties with business partners by judiciously applying social networking tools to their marketing efforts. But for most firms, I'm betting it's a waste of time and money.

Business to business marketing is a different kettle of fish than consumer marketing. And it should appear obvious to readers of the Social Media B2B site. In a post on the main page called B2B Buyers Are Social, the item's contention is based on a Forrester research report that the blogger says, "states that buyers in the B2B area are one of the most social groups around."

(So, it must be true, right? Just like all those Standard and Poors and Moody's reports on how sound U.S. financial markets were.)

Now, don't get me wrong. I'm sure B2B buyers as social animals are probably right up there with Paris Hilton. But as business people doing their jobs to assess products and services? Think again.

In that same post, the author quotes another blogger who claims that B2B marketers not already on the social media bandwagon now "means you're late." The blogger points to Forrester's Groundswell awards as proof.

Well, I'm not sure about you, but my reading of who won these awards is that, with the possible exception of Nerd Network, B2B social networks are conspicuously missing from the winners' circle. But even the Nerd Network is really an old-fashioned forum for end users of a business tool. And forums, even tarted up with a social media user interface, are not exactly cutting edge marketing activities.

Yes, yes, social networking is all the rage. Twitter is growing by leaps and bounds. Facebook is the next Google. And who needs the New York Times when you've got snarky news reports on Reddit? But as a tool for B2B marketers, it's a fad in search of purpose. Then there's a real possibility you'll inadvertently infect your B2B partners' computers with new social media malware. Won't that be fun to explain.

I'm sure there will be scant examples of where it makes some sense, but is it the cost-effective tool most B2B marketers need in these tough times to generate more business?

No.

 

What People Are Saying

I respectfully disagree with you, Mark

There are a multitude of online forums and social networking groups where b2b buyers are having conversations about technology and consuming information from like-minded peers that ultimately contributes to decision-making. Is that happening to the same degree in traditional media? What about other marketing techniques - are they facilitating that kind of interaction? Whitepapers maybe?

On this page I see a banner ad for NetApp. I wonder if that would compel someone to run out and buy it. More realistically, the potential buyer will search the Web for unbiased opinions, like this LinkedIn thread comprised of 110 discussions about NetApp products:

http://www.linkedin.com/searchAnswers?results=&sik=1238016725423&pplSearchOrigin=GLHD&keywords=netapp

And no, simply creating a Twitter feed or Facebook group doesn't constitute great b2b social marketing either. Your post is provocative but makes massive generalizations about social media, where b2b audiences spend time, what influences purchasing behavior and cost effectiveness.

On that note, how much is a big traditional b2b marketing campaign going for these days?

Joseph Kingsbury
www.text100.com

B2B and Social Media

Investing in social media is not a waste of resources (time or money) for the B2B industry. It's a great way to introduce a b2b service and connect with potential clients through conversations instead of simply yelling about what you have to offer via traditional advertising spaces. And isn’t that the conversation we want to have in the first place?

RE: Hey, Stranger: Social media meets B2B

Mark,

First of all that you for mentioning our new project Social Media B2B in your blog. We are look at social media and B2B companies in more ways than just marketing. Internal communications and customer service will be two other big areas of focus.

You make strong point but I disagreed with you (not surprisingly) that social media for B2B marketing is a fad. All media will be social and understanding this wil lbe central to the success of any company B2C or B2B.

I would truly love to discuss this issue with you for a post on Social Media B2B.

Would you be interested in doing a recorded phone call or a recorded video chat that would be part of a post that discusses the validity of social media marketing for B2B companies?

Would be honored if you would take the time to discuss further.

Thank you,
Kipp Bodnar
@kbodnar32
kipp.bodnar AT gmailDOTcom

B2B marketing

Marketing on social networks is all the rage. Strengthening relationships with business partners and consumers is a important and can be done on social netoworks. B2B social network marketing also increases awareness about your competition and ultimately creates stroner bonds withing your industry. -Annalise www.ezanga.com