Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Preston Gralla's picture
Preston Gralla

Seeing Through Windows

How to protect yourself against Google ad snooping

Earlier this week, Google announced that it had begun using so-called behavioral targeting, meaning that it tracks your interests, stores that information in a cookie, then sends you ads based on your online behavior. Worried that it invades your privacy? Here's how to protect yourself, while still taking advantage of all that Google has to offer.

Privacy advocates have been critical of behavioral targeting, which is already used by other Web sites such as Yahoo. However, on its blog, Google explains its new use of behavioral targeting not in terms of privacy, but as a way of "making ads more interesting." Speaking as someone who isn't a particularly big fan of advertising, I'd say the only way to make ads more interesting would be to have them tell the truth. But I'll leave that fantasy aside for now.

How does Google do the actual tracking of your interests? It collects information from your use of YouTube, and from its AdSense network. And it also tracks you when you visit sites of advertisers. Here, from a New York Times article, is the best description of how it works:

Google is collecting information from YouTube and the sites in its AdSense network — those on which it sells both text and display ads. When you see an ad on one of those sites, Google’s computers will read the page you are on and try to figure out what it is about so it can associate you with one or more categories on its list.

Separately, Google is now adding "retargeting" to the AdSense network. The company will record when you visit the sites of certain advertisers, and you will be shown ads for that company on the pages of other sites that display ads sold by Google. For example, if you check the prices of roses on a flower site, you may see rose ads for a week. This concept was developed 10 years ago by DoubleClick, which Google bought last year.

Although Google is being criticized for behavioral targeting, it deserves plenty of kudos for the way in which it lets you opt out of that targeting, and the clear way in which it explains what it's doing. It's a model that other sites should emulate. In fact, the New York Times says that it may well become a Web-wide model, and may even halt potential government regulation:

Given Google’s position as the No. 1 seller of online ads, its approach is likely to put pressure on other companies to follow suit. Online advertising industry groups said it might help quell calls for government regulation.

First off, you can see what Google determines your interests to be, which in turn determines what ads Google shows you. Head to the Google Ad Preferences page. As you can see in the screenshot below, not only does it show you your interests, but it lets you change those interests. You can also opt out by clicking the Opt out button. And the site even shows you the cookie which stores your information.

 

You can also opt out by visiting this page, which includes a great deal of information about Google's advertising and privacy policies.

However, even when you do that, it's no guarantee that the cookie won't end up tracking you again. That's because the opt out function tells the cookie not to track you. So if you delete that cookie for any reason, the next time you go to Google, you'll get a new tracking cookie. However, Google has a browser plug-in that will keep you opted out permanently. Go here to get it for your browser.

What People Are Saying

I am an unusually active www

I am an unusually active www user, and Google is my only "homepage"; all of my many searches use Google, I have a gmail account, and browse Youtube occasionally.

To its credit Google has correctly interpreted all of my activity and reports that "No interest categories are associated with your ads preferences so far."

I take that to mean that my searches and browsing are varied enough, and non-commercial enough, that Google has recognized that I have no interest in commercialized product, including media product. Good for Google.

It seems that if the http://www.google.com/ads/preferences page is showing our "interest categories" that is a consequence of our browsing behavior - and our own responsibility to account for.

COMPLETE opt out

If you want to opt out of being tracked by ALL of the advertising networks, someone has collected all of the opt out buttons into one click here:

http://www.privacychoice.net

you have no privacy per H.R. 6304 Title 2

Title II, “Protections for Electronic Communication Service Providers,” provides, in Section
201, retroactive immunity from civil suits involving intelligence activity authorized by the
President under the Terrorist Surveillance Program between September 11, 2001 and January
17, 2007 (TSP), upon request of the Attorney General. Federal district courts must review the
certifications requesting immunity to ensure their compliance with the requirements set forth in
this bill (under a “substantial evidence” standard). This title also provides prospective
immunity for carriers who cooperate with the intelligence community pursuant to strictly
defined requests, and preempts state investigations of the federal government’s intelligence
collection activities under FISA.

Not a fan of advertising?

Not a fan of advertising? Where do you think your salary comes from? Look at the ads around this page. If you are not a fan, remove them and keep blogging for free.

Thanks for listening.

Ads on this page? I don't

Ads on this page? I don't see any ads on this page. In fact I don't see any ads on any page.

What are you, a 10 year old using IE3?

Hint - it only takes a decent browser and one plugin to eliminate virtually every ad on the net.

Idiot.

I actually do think targeted

I actually do think targeted advertising is more interesting, and it can even be useful. Because sometimes ads do inform us of products and service we are actually interested in. Facebook uses targeted advertising based on your profile interests, and this has alerted me to concert dates for bands that I am interested. I would have never seen the ad without targeted advertising (not an extremely popular band), and I would not have known of the tour without the ad. "Recommendation" features on sites like Amazon are also effectively targeted advertising, and most people actually like that.

Come on....lets not forget

Come on....lets not forget that services like g-mail, google web search, google earth, etc. are all FREE. I am sick of hearing the whining about how everyone wants there FREE services served to them on a golden platter. If you don't want to be advertised at then don't use their services. And if you are going to use there services, isn't it better to see that new car you've been lusting after instead of a new popcorn maker.

Lets stop the whining and maybe even donate a dollar or two to that software you ripped off the Internet and thank that kind developer for putting the time in to make this website available.

Oh..wait a minute...how did I find this website? I believe it was through the preferences on my google news page. Thanks Google!

Just use a hosts file to

Just use a hosts file to block DoubleClick. :)

http://www.mvps.org/winhelp2002/hosts.htm

Or if you use Firefox the CustomizeGoogle extension, and use scroogle to search.

I signed up for

I signed up for advertising!

I really dislike advertising myself. But if I'm going to use Google's services I'm going to expect being advertised at.

So I used the Google Ad Preferences page to sign up for advertising I want! Hahaha! Might as well get something relevant if I have to get it.

Get it correct...or you don't get it!

This is why I hate Google…look at the very bottom of the artcle…where it says that in order to be permently opted out of the tracking, you HAVE to install a plugin….meaning…that google will check for a certain cookie, if it doesn’t find it, it will create it and keep tracking…..so…the choice is install a freagin plugin or keep this freagin file…..

Way to stick it to everyone GOOGLE…reall nice!

BTW...ur comment about the opt out function "telling the cookie not to track you" is incorrect...the cookie is a file, as such it doesn't "do" anything as your statement implies. The prescense of the file and its contents are used and interpreted by the webpage.

Long story short, enable session cookies only and you won't see that tracking throughout the week, you will see the tracking in the current session ( if it works as described)

Cheers