Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Preston Gralla's picture
Preston Gralla

Seeing Through Windows

IE8's new WebSlices feature: Welcome to 1997

Anyone who used computers in 1997 might get a feeling of deja vu when they use one of Internet Explorer 8's most-hyped new features, WebSlices. WebSlices seems like nothing so much as a clone of the ill-fated, ill-conceived, very buggy Active Desktop rolled out back in 1997 with Internet Explorer 4.

Come with me on the Wayback Machine for a moment or two and I'll describe Active Desktop to you. Active Desktop worked a lot like widgets and Vista gadgets do today --- it grabbed information from the Web, and displayed it on your desktop in a little widget. Microsoft said that Active Desktop items are:

...live content that Internet Explorer 4.0 lets you bring from the Web to your Active Desktop...You'll find cool items that deliver regularly updated news, entertainment, tools, and more.

Here's a screenshot of one of the Active Desktop widgets from back then:

Active Desktop

The description of Active Desktop is very nearly an exact description of the new WebSlices feature in IE8. They do exactly what Active Desktop was designed to do --- grab information from the Web, and display it in a kind of widget inside Internet Explorer. Here's a WebSlice that Microsoft shows off today:

IE8 WebSlice

Ironically, back in 1997 on a page about Active Desktop, Microsoft was touting an MSNBC Weather Map --- and today, it's touting MSN Weather as a WebSlice. The more things change, apparently, the more they stay the same.

What ever happened to Active Desktop? It was a fiasco. It sucked up an enormous amount of system resources and slowed systems to a crawl. It crashed PCs. It was extraordinarily slow, because back in 1997, most people were still using dial-up modems. It died a slow, painful death.

So why did Microsoft go back to the future with WebSlices? Because Active Desktop was actually quite a good idea, but was way ahead of its time and implemented poorly. Processor speed, RAM, technology and bandwidth finally caught up.

It's unclear, though, whether WebSlices will actually catch on. It requires that content providers create content for it, and developers include code on their Web sites to allow it. And it remains to be seen whether that will happen.

For a more in-depth look at IE8, including WebSlices, check out my blog Five things you'll love (or hate) about IE8. And to see an archived page about Active Desktop, click here. Note that some graphics are missing in the archived page.

[Like this blog? Subscribe to the RSS feed here!]

What People Are Saying

Webslices is a joke compared

Webslices is a joke compared to the Interclue add-on for Firefox.

left out a step...

That should have read, "Right click on desktop, Properties, Desktop, Customize, Web." Looks like watered down Active Desktop to me.

speaking of...

Isn't there still a stripped-down version of this? Right-click on the desktop, Properties, Desktop, Web. I don't use this but it looks similar.

Also, Google Gadgets is pretty much the same as Yahoo Widgets (Konfabulator) and Active Desktop, and I think there are one or two more I'm forgetting. Personally, I would never use such a thing, as I keep all my windows maximized. A sidebar, on the other hand, with everything visible at all times-- ala Google Desktop and now Yahoo Widgets-- that's an idea that will last.

IE8 Will Continue to Suck More or Less

The creeping incrementalism remains evident. Microsoft should get the credit for being innovative from Day One but they hoisted themselves on their own petard and in the end just about everything they have done is half-@ssed crippled trash.

For example, we already have a sidebar running in Windows Office applications and in IE since IE4 was released. In IE this sidebar is what the Micromorons call a Research TaskPane.

So when credit is due it really is due. That Research TaskPane was not only misnamed by the Micromorons they also left it crippled and unaccessible as extending it is possible but not documented well.

Microslop has done nothing worth respecting with regards to supporting IE extensibility in any way that still requires C++ and Win32 programming skills.

This really sucks in comparsion to what has been made possible for those using Firefox built on Mozilla.

In IE for example go View > Explorer Bar > Research.

What is now called a TaskPane (in Office) but Research (in IE) should have had an SDK long long ago that allowed us lowly ASP.NET developers to create user interfaces that functioned as little mini-website applications so many customers have asked for and dare I presume to say actually pay for in certain contexts.

Meanwhile, it sure looks to me like the Micromorons still intend to try to impose their will using bravo sierra releasing IE8 which appears to be nothing more than more half-@ssed crippleware.

Favorites remain broken down unmanageable trash renamed and moved to a list providing nothing more than what will result in more of the same: a great big long list of unmanageable inextensible trash in a big fat closed trash can.

Webslices and Activities are shallow promises that will not pan out because IE itself is extensible. There is no business model for developers and partners to work with.

Widgets never died out

Yahoo! Konfabulator was created for the same purpose...

Success requires that people

Success requires that people actually want the feature. Why is that always left out of consideration?