Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Seth Weintraub's picture
Seth Weintraub

Apple versus Google

Is Apple trading SD cards for DVDs in MacBooks?

Last month, most of Apple's MacBooks were upgraded with SD card slots. The most popular 13- and 15-inch MacBook Pros both now have card readers. Apple even explains how to build a bootable SD card. Why on earth would Apple go through the trouble of explaining how to create a boot disk from an SD card? That seems way out in left field. They never did that for USB key drives.

I think there is more to it than that. Apple doesn't just do things like SD cards. "You can just throw in a USB SD card reader" had been the mantra up until this point. Apple didn't need to bother itself with these little things.

Now, I think things have changed. The SD card has become part of Apple's MacBook strategy. It should be arriving on the MacBook Air and the regular MacBook at the next updates...and it might even take the place of the DVD drive on the next MacBook.

That's right, I think the SD card is going to replace the DVD drive on most of Apple's laptops going forward. If you really need a DVD, you'll be able to buy an external USB Superdrive - but that option will mostly be a safety net.

Remember when Apple killed the floppy with the iMac? This will be the same thing. You could buy external floppy but how many of you really did?

Think about it. What would you rather have on your laptop? An easily rewritable 32GB SD card the size of a postage stamp that can hold about the same amount of data as 8 DVDs or a big spinning disk that can scratch easily and takes up about 1/4th of the internal usable area in your laptop?

It is a no-brainer; optical is over.

With compression much better than antiquated DVDs, a full-length, DVD-quality movie can fit on a 1GB SD card, with much room to spare. SD cards cost about $2/GB. DVDs are cheaper, but cost really isn't an issue.

Backing up to an SD card is much better than trying to deal with DVDs. You can even use Time Machine with SD. 8GB DVDs won't hold most people's photo albums. However, a 32GB SD card should be able to knock out the casual user's home directory.

Even BluRay movies can largely fit on today's SD cards. Tomorrow's will be much bigger (though Apple hasn't announced support for those yet - the max is 32GB).

And that's before you consider that Apple wants you downloading your HD movies from iTunes rather than buying physical media. Apple is also pushing packaging to ever smaller sizes. SD cards are much more durable than DVDs and are so small they can be swallowed.

So, if we are no longer burdened with big optical drives in our laptops, what are we going to do with all of that space?

I think a 15-inch MacBook Air would certainly be an entertaining idea. If you look at the space in a 15-inch laptop, a huge chunk is taken up by the DVD.

I also like the idea of having more than one SSD/HDD slot in the laptop. Perhaps a small, speedy 1.8 inch SSD drive for the OS/settings/applications and a huge 500GB HDD for media? That sounds about right to me.

There will always be those who cling to their old technology. How will you install software? (Heard of this thing called the App Store?) How will you install the OS? Remember, above, Apple showed us how to build a boot disk from the SD card. That probably comes from experience.

People will complain that they can't watch their DVD collection. What are they going to do with all of their old DVDs? (Get HandBrake).

Remember how indispensable the floppy was?

What People Are Saying

MBP - Optical Drive = MBPAir?

Just a thought, but what would happen with the whole lineup of portables if Apple were to remove the optical drive from the MBPs? Would the MBA just disappear? Seeing as it would be underpowered and have no advantages over the MBPs, how would it still exist? Perhaps it could be a netbook-esque product...? That would be one hell of a "netbook".

SD vs DVD

Here's a twist for all you nae sayer's out there.

DVD(Blue Ray) to SD card converter; basically a SD slot in a DVD reader that one button copies the DVD to a SD card. Now put that in one of the Red Box movie rental kiosks and let people load their rented movie onto their own SD card. Go home and play the movie as many times as you'd like for 24 hours then the Software on the card would automatically delete the movie. No need to return anything, no more late fees (wait, video rental businesses would never go for that).

There's a whole industry out there waiting for the SD card to take over. Think of the possibilities...

Oh My God!

That's pure genius!

Poor SD Slot Design

I'll buy the move from DVD to SDHC, but you CANNOT use an SD card slot that leaves the card exposed. End of story. That makes the device merely a card reader. Why even bother making it bootable - you don't dare leave it in the computer in your bag.

Optical vs SD

Also I am very tired of the tablet/touch-computer rumors, but let me give you these thoughts...
I think that if Apple will introduce a the famous Netbook, tablet-pc or however you want to call the thing between iPhone and MacBook, it will certainly have no optical drive but just SD-card slot.
An optical drive will come just as for the MB Air or even sweeter, it will accessible via Airport.

Actually if SD-card will replace the optical drives, a wireless accessible drive is a must. As you can today already share optical drives.

Or you have e.g. an Airport Xtreme with HD and optical drive.

Or the external optical-drive has a SD-card slot and a one button-function to copy the content from CD/DVD to the SD-card.

Or....

Lot of solutions possible which can make an optical drive in the laptop obsolete

And one more thing...

This honestly seems realistic. If you look at this realistically, SD replacing DVDs and CDs would be a really good move on the industryโ€™s part. SD has so many advantages over DVDs and CDs including size/GB ratio and space efficiency. If you think about it, removing the optical drives from a computer opens up real estate in the system leaving room for the logic board, memory, HDD/SDD and of course the battery. If this happened to the desktops as well, the same opportunities open up but there is no battery. Think of what would happen to the Mac Pro. With those two optical drives removed, who knows whatโ€™ll replaced it (8TB of storage?)! Which would you rather have: a small compact chip that, later this year, will be capable of holding 2TB of storage, or a big spinning disk that gets scratched easily, takes up much space, and takes up about 1/4 of you systems internal space? If this transition does take place, there will be alternatives, like the MacBook Air external superdrive. Itโ€™ll probably be renamed to the Apple External Superdrive and might even have support for BluRay. After about a year theyโ€™ll discontinue it. Then thereโ€™s the MacBook modelโ€™s. Theyโ€™ll probably introduce a 15โ€ MacBook Air with either an express card slot or and SD card slot and the 13โ€ will probably get an SD card slot. The MacBook Proโ€™s could get a huge boost in battery life, speed, storage, and probably memory and the price might drop to $999 for the 13โ€. The current MacBook might be redesigned to be a netbook with a 10โ€ screen and an aluminum unibody casing. So theyโ€™ll have a 10โ€ MacBook, a 13โ€ and 15โ€ MacBook Air, and a 13โ€, 15โ€ and 17โ€ MacBook Pro. As for the desktops, the Mac Mini will get a huge redesign, with shell being completely aluminum and the hard drive getting a boost up to a terabyte of storage, a way faster processor, memory up to 8GB and an SD card slot. The iMac could get a hard drive boost and an SD card slot, and the Mac Proโ€™s specs will be amazing. As for your DVD collection, get HandBrake and get started. OS upgrades will probably be sold in SD form and minor software could be sold on the App store. The majority of media will be sold over the web. Your entertainment center will be upgraded. Imagine an SD card player instead of a DVD player or simply just get Apple TV.

And then there are game systems which will probably go the path of the Nintendo DSi.

Jumping the gun, much?

Now steady on there, we're just past the introduction of the SD reader and you're talking about redesigning the Mac Pro to do away with the DVD trays.

Now, whilst I most certainly approve of the inclusion of the SD card, it for one makes the transfer of video from my camcorder an awful lot simpler, I really cannot see it killing the DVD within the next few revision cycles.

Yes, the iMac killed the floppy disk. For Apple. My father bought a Dell in '06 and it has a floppy drive. However I really cannot see the same for the SD card. Think of it this way, go into your local PC World, Currys, Comet, Fenwicks, Pattinsons, whatever, and look at the capacity of the cards. And look at the prices. And you'll buy a spindle of DVDs.

Apple seems to be playing evolution not revolution. The DVD will be phased out when its time is due; when SD cards are readily available with capacities far beyond that of even Blu-Ray discs at competitive prices. Remember, the MacBook Air is not missing a DVD drive because of the SD card; the MBA is missing its DVD drive because there was no room for one in the first place.

Perfect comment. You just

Perfect comment. You just said it all.

I'm Not Jumping The Gun

The SD card has been out long enough for us to see it's timeline.
The capacity of the SD is more efficient than a dual layer bluray disk and they are easily rewritable. Don't forget about the SDXC card that's coming out later this year and it'll be capable of 2TB. The only reason why disks are cheap is because the majority of them aren't rewritable. Apparently the DVD's time is due in the near future. The MacBook Air was introduced in 2008 which was before this speculation was taken into consideration. I'm pretty sure that a simple remodel will make an SD card reader fit at the same thickness of the system.

Right

I think you hit the nail on the head with this comment, I agree completely.