Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Seth Weintraub's picture
Seth Weintraub

Apple versus Google

Is Google Wave the spork of the Internet?

Google did it again today, overshadowing Microsoft's Bing search engine offering with what be their most ambitious project yet. Google Wave is described as what email would be like if it were invented right now.

It is a little of everything all mashed up into one giant framework. Wave is part email, IM, calendar, Twitter, wiki, spreadsheets/docs/presentation, picture sharing, social media, forums, maps and just about everything else on the web. In fact, it took an hour and a half to explain the whole thing (below).

It seems pretty apparant that Google wants this to be Gmail 2.0 at some point in the coming years. It will also fit alongside (or over) the current apps for business. But is this a good thing?


Maybe this is my getting old, but I am not sure I am fully buying in yet. When I am rolling out new software to a company, someone always asks, "Why can't the current software just do [what the new software is doing], why do we have to learn yet another application?"

An existential example that usually makes a lot of sense is silverware.

Instead of using a fork, knife and spoon, what if people were forced to just us a spork? Is this the best solution to eating? The software industry is the same way. One tool isn't always better than a combination of different tools.

Perhaps I am stuck in my ways, but I worry that Google is going to trip up on the complexity and ambition of this new program. Even though it is open and available to developers, it might not do everything a person or business needs. Will it play nice with other applications? Will other applications play nice with it?

It's all way too early to tell.

I should say that I am excited about this Google project, however. In fact, I am thinking that the best Internet forum application anywhere could be hammered out of Wave in a few hours...BRB.

Related Stories: Google Watch

What People Are Saying

Twitter With Google Wave

Hi

How can I check my twitter account I am new in wave and now I want to add this into my wave

Twitter With Google Wave

Hi

How can I check my twitter account I am new in wave and now I want to add this into my wave

not impressed.

not impressed.

voting yes to google wave

Yes its hype, but yes it makes an awefull lot of sense and checks all the right boxes.

1. replaces email (lets face its sloowwww, y shoudl it take ten minutes for me to recieve one email???)

2. Instant messaging with out even realising it.

3. open source! YES YES YES

4. DECENTRALISED YES YES YES YES

ok sorry im excited.

Wave = OLPC activity collaborative mesh networking. No?

After watching this entire Wave video on youtube, I was more and more put in mind of the activity collaboration mesh networking concept brought about within the Sugar UI on the One Laptop Per Child (OLPC) project.

Wave seems, at least in part, to be an elaborate version of that. No?

I see a lot of people misunderstanding what Wave is

A lot of people are looking at Wave like it's a new GMail or something. It isn't.

It's more like a new Email. It's a protocol, a set of standards, and is not "centralised" at Google in any way.

Anybody can be a Wave provider. Anybody can write a Wave front end. At its simplest, Wave is a way for 2 or more people to concurrently edit an XML document. That's it.

So why would Google do this? Simple. They want the web to be more useful than the desktop. Google Wave is Google's way of waving goodbye to Microsoft. With the power of statistical, whole-web language models and open federation, the web just took a generational leap forward. Make no mistake.

Just my 2c.

Dan

I concur.

Dan. You're the Man.
Author/journalist dude: You should find a new job.

Wave will change the way we communicate online, fundamentally! The prospects are both scary and exciting!

Google: Hype vs Reality

Google is the King Of Search, but they don't excel at anything else.

They are better at generating hype, than they are at delivering quality products.

Google Apps, for example, has hardly turned out to be the MS Office Killer that it was touted to be.

Wrong

Google Apps was never meant to replace MS Office; it was meant to fill a niche below the all-powerful word processor, augmented with online collaboration features.
Please get your facts straight before making an argument next time.

Unified communication has been tried many times before

Google Wave may just be the next Microsoft Bob.

I'm sure it demos well, but nothing I've seen suggests it will be a game-changer. It appears to be one of a long list of applications that have attempted to unify communications by treating different communication channels as if they had the same interaction metaphor. Google is far from the first company to try this, and won't be the last.