Ads by TechWords
Subscribe to our e-mail newsletters
For more info on a specific newsletter, click the title. Details will be displayed in a new window.
Computerworld Daily News (First Look and Wrap-Up)
Computerworld Blogs Newsletter
The Weekly Top 10
More E-Mail Newsletters 
Joyce Carpenter's picture
Joyce Carpenter

Philosophy of Technology

IT is sexy?

Viviane Reding, the European Union's information society commissioner, thinks she has a way to help make up for a projected shortage of IT workers according to IDG News Service.

"We have to convince young women that [Information and Communications Technologies] (ICTs) isn't just for geeks. IT jobs can be very sexy indeed," Reding told journalists at the Commission's briefing Thursday.

According to a related press release, the "proportion of female graduates ... remains low in engineering degrees where only 19% were female in 2004."

Reding is part of a program designed "to do something about the lack of women in IT careers. Together with several leading technology companies – the Commission organised a series of 'shadowing days' to show young women that technology is not at all 'strictly for geeks!'."

As part of a video about the program, Reding says that technology is real magic. "All you need for a successful career in ICTs is a sense of curiosity, and willingness to learn new things, but also a very important dose of courage and a spirit of adventure to face unexpected challenges." When she says it, it sounds easy and maybe even fun.

While Europe is focusing on developing it's own talent, here in the U.S. Bill Gates is arguing that the cap on H-1B visas should be raised. Maybe it should, maybe it shouldn't, but I wonder what Microsoft is doing to attract women to IT careers both here in the U.S. and around the world.

Cisco seems to be a significant sponsor of International Women's Day (last Saturday, in case you missed it) and says:

* Through our Women’s Action Network (more than 3000 employees based in 24 countries) we cultivate mentoring and career development opportunities for women.
* Cisco's Girls/Women in Technology Initiative aims to introduce more female students to technology and inspire excitement in associated careers.

Several Computerworld readers commented on the need for mentoring in response to our article about women in IT last summer. Both female and male readers pointed to the need for work/life balance to keep everyone in IT.

It all sounds good, but what's being accomplished? Has the percentage of women in IT significantly increased? Are tech companies actually making life easier for employees? Is IT an attractive and rational career choice?

What People Are Saying

Rate this
Rated +147
2209 Votes

Women in Engineering

When I was getting my BS in EE there were 279 incoming freshmen, 278 men 1 women.
By the second year there were 24 men 0 women.
Third year 16 men 0 women.
Fourth year 6 men 0 women.
Then one day in my senior year I was sitting in class at the start of a new semester. The professor was the WEED THEM OUT type. He graded his class on a curve to fail half the class, thus the drop in the number of students each year. A new FEMALE face walked in and sat down, heads turned. I asked her what class she thought this was. She was obviously upset and seemed to take my remark as an insult to her gender. I tried to tell her that you can't just come in here cold and expect to pass. She told me that she had several degrees and was a 4.0 student(the highest GPA in my class was a 2.6!)
I told her if she wanted to keep her 4.0 to drop the class. She didn't listen. She did get a C in the class(impressive!), I tried to congratulate her and she was in tears(It took me two tries to get a C!)
This professor had been teaching for 27 years and had NEVER given a student an A , and only five B's!

My point is that us male students were happy to have a female colleague, we would do whatever it took to screw up the other guy because of the curve, yet we went out of our way to help her.
It's the 21'st century, many of us have been raised by strong single women, most of our teachers are female.

It's just a different world for my generation, the idea that women are somehow excluded from Engineering sounds a little odd to someone my age.

As for your last question "Is IT an attractive and rational career choice?"

I went into CS and Engineering because I was born to it, and love it. As a career it's a dead end sink hole, long hours low pay, no respect and offshored or replaced at the drop of a hat.

I'm a fifth generation Engineer on my mothers side and a third generation on my fathers, two of my uncles are engineers as are several cousins.

If you want money and a home life, IT is not for you.