Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Mike Elgan's picture
Mike Elgan

The World Is My Office

It's official: In-flight cell phone talking is un-American

ATHENS, GREECE -- While Europe and the Middle East move aggressively to allow cell phone conversations on airplanes, the country that invented both the cell phone and the airplane wants no part of it. A new poll found that three-quarters of U.S. consumers are against allowing cell phone talking in-flight.

The poll, commissioned by Yahoo and conducted by Harris Interactive found that, although 74 percent of respondents support a ban on actual cell phone conversations, 60 percent actually approve of allowing cell phones to be used for e-mail, text messaging and instant messaging.

And there were regional differences. Some 83 percent of people in the "West" wanted the cell phone ban, while just 69 percent of Southerners want people banned from talking in airplanes.

Pollsters also grilled consumers on another hypothetical scenario: If cell phone talking was allowed in flight, should there be a cell phone "section" for the talkers? More than two-thirds (69 percent) said yes.

I personally don't support the ban on cell phones in-flight, and have proposed etiquette as an alternative, but I understand why people don't want to be trapped inside the fuselage of a cross-country airplane with an annoying yakker. I don't understand why anyone would oppose the silent use of cell phones, for texting, surfing the web and so on. According to the Yahoo poll, however, 40 percent actually oppose the silent use of cell phones in-flight. Is this rational?

As smart phones get smarter, and become more useful as web surfing and text-based communication tools, I think we should be setting up the airplane shielding and relay equipment -- and the rules -- for allowing this basic use of phones in-flight.

What People Are Saying

When I am disturbed by

When I am disturbed by discourteous cell phone usage while in a bus, restaurant, or other public place, I can choose to leave. In an airplane, this is not possible. Often, one cannot even change one's seat. I am all for airborne technology (I fly with my cell, Kindle, and laptop)but fights will break out between volume-impaired boors and the rest of us.

.... Why?

Cellphones aren't banned on buses, restaurants or any other public place, why should they be banned in airplanes? People aren't going to have the mentality of "Hey, i'm on a plane, I better talk on my cellphone for 3 hours straight!". Obviously common courtesy would be expected, but banning cellphones is absurd in my humble opinion.

Of course they would..

It is not unusual for a person to conduct a
phone conversation driving to the store,
shopping, paying for his/her purchases, and
driving home; and it is the same conversation!

You actually think that same person would not
talk until their battery ran out??!!

My objection to cell phone

My objection to cell phone use on the plane has nothing to do with safety, which is pretty much a made-up argument. It has to do entirely with etiquette.

We Americans are among the worst people in the world at giving any consideration to those around us. And my non-scientific observations are that the greater number of cell phone users insist on raising their voices 10 decibels when they're talking. I see - or rather hear - this every day on the train home from work (people tend to be quieter in the morning, before they're fully awake). If you can talk on your phone without raising your voice any louder than you would to talk to your neighbor, fine. Otherwise, save it until later. The airplane is a shared space, and I, the one who has a cell phone for emergencies and because it's cheaper than land-line long distance, have my rights, too.

mobile on planes

Well, perhaps the 40% are the people who actually believe the airlines/FAA that mobile phones are tools of satan and interfere with airline equipment, thus reason to not enable it.

Actually, the 40% probably

Actually, the 40% probably consists (at least partly) of people that use the flight time to disconnect from the biz world. I know that I use that time to do a little catch-up. Being available via email/txt means little or no 'quiet time'...

mobile on planes

I tend to agree with you, Steve, with the exception that I believe that loud and annoying cell-phone yakkers are the tools of Satan while the 40% that are afraid of any cell phone use just haven't received the message from on high yet. Perhaps we should text them?

As for in-flight use:

SMS & Internet use on Cell phones, Kindles, PDAs, etc. == good.

Yakking in a closed space next to folks that don't care how bad your bunions hurt == bad.

Unfortunately, if cell phone

Unfortunately, if cell phone use is allowed on airplanes, there are air-headed twits (not to be confused with twitters or twatters) that obnoxiously converse on their cells without regard to those around them; and they would certainly take license to do so in flight if given the opportunity.
jr