Introverted and proud of it
- IT TOPICS:Careers, Management
Several readers have thanked columnist Ira Winkler for his piece, So, what's wrong with being an introvert? My favorite from the mailbag: "I'm not interested in social interaction at work, I'm interested in programming," wrote one reader who describes himself as a top-notch programmer. "I cannot put in print how strongly I detest having to deal with end-users' computer-related angst. The day I never have to answer another Help Desk call will be the greatest day of my life. And the last thing I would ever want to be is a manager of other programmers. We're un-manageable! Just leave us alone and let us program."
He's got a point. If someone is truly an excellent coder yet doesn't have good people skills, what's to be gained by taking him away from programming and putting him on the phone? Is the problem an incomplete employee or bad management? Perhaps the employee isn't a good fit for the job, and would be better off in another place.
Wrote another IT worker: "We need intros and extros. I have no use for social clowns, wizards or other entertainers."
This all started when editor in chief Don Tennant chastised a Carnegie Mellon professor for saying IT pros have a deserved reputation as "socially inept introverts," in his editorial, Stigma by stereotype. That prompted a blizzard of response, which Don included in his editorial this week, The stigma debate. (One comment: "I think that 'socially inept' is putting it kindly. At the place I work now, most of my co-workers have the charm and social grace of potatoes.")
Whether the stereotype of IT pro as socially challenged nerd is fair, it's certainly true that at least some tech workers are in fact introverts. If they're also highly talented introverts, a company would be better off taking maximum advantage of those talents instead of putting them in positions where they're forced to be extroverts.
--Sharon Machlis, online managing editor
Related Opinion:
- Don Tennant: Stigma by Stereotype
- Ira Winkler: So, what's wrong with being an introvert?
- John Monaghan: Stereotypes and perceptions
- Don Tennant: The Stigma Debate
- Mailbag: Introverted and proud of it



