Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


IT Blogwatch's picture
IT Blogwatch

A Daily Digest of IT Blogs from Richi Jennings

Zune vs. iPod (and dunking stats.)

Listen to this: it's IT Blogwatch, in which Microsoft launches Zune, to compete with Apple's iPod. Not to mention vital cookie dunking statistics...

Elizabeth Montalbano has the four-one-one:

Microsoft's Zune music player to ship in time for holidays. Rival to iPod features wireless technology, FM tuner ... will hit U.S. retailers in time for the busy holiday season, with a 30GB digital media player and an online media marketplace the first to reach consumers ... similar to what Apple already offers, with a couple of exceptions. In addition to allowing users to play music, videos and photos on a screen, the Zune player will include wireless technology and a built-in FM radio tuner. So far, iPods lack either radio tuners or built-in wireless technology.

Zune's wireless technology will allow users to share songs, playlists and photos between Zune devices, Microsoft said. A user can listen to any song received up to three times over three days, after which the listener  must buy  it from the Zune Marketplace to continue listening.
...
If other attempts to unseat the iPod are any indication, Microsoft will have a tough road ahead. Recently, Dell Inc. stopped selling its DJ Ditty music player on its Web site and ended development of its own line of music players.

Still, iPod market share has fallen in the past year, leaving room for rivals in the market. At one point the music player had more than 80% market share by analysts estimates, but the latest reports give the iPod a little over 70% market share.

John Biggs gets the social networking angle:

The Zune has 802.11 networking built in and you can send a song to your friend ... The goal, obviously, is to sell music. However, we could also conceivably see this as a MySpace-like network of users who pop music to each other with giddy abandon and infect others with their musical stylings on the train (perhaps a sandwich board that says “I’ll Send My New HARDCORE RAP Single to Your Zune. Talk to me. Please?”) Once you get back home you can connect to the Zune Marketplace - and presumably an artists home page - where you can learn more and buy music.

Clearly all the data isn’t in yet, but this definitely pushes the MP3 player out of the pocket and into the realm of social networking. The question, obviously, is what is Apple going to do about this and, as a corrallary, how low Apple and Creative shares are selling as we speak? Perhaps MS could create a “Zune Inside” logo for those guys? Or maybe fund a halfway house for underconnected MP3 players?

Staci Kramer adds:

Years ago people got a kick out of beaming Palm cards, now Microsoft hope Zune owners will wirelessly share music, playlists and pictures. It’s not music-sharing nirvana: song sharing is limited to homemade recordings and full-length “sample tracks of select songs.” Users can listen to any song that’s received up to three times over three days — gack, more exploding media — then can flag a desired song on the device and buy it from the Zune Marketplace.

Carl Howe says Microsoft's thrown away its hope to steal Christmas from Apple:

Two days after Apple refreshed and lowered the prices on its iPod line (and thereby wrought havoc on Microsoft's launch plans), Microsoft today announced its own 30 Gigabyte Zune music player. This first product in the Zune line is, in fact, a rebadged Toshiba Gigabeat.
...
But from a marketing point of view, this was not really an announcement, since Microsoft neither announced the price nor made the product available to consumers. Microsoft also declined to mention a launch date. Yet, the lack of any actual product didn't stop Microsoft from immediately positioning Zune as a platform.
...
But consumers don't care about platforms. They want music players that look cool, work seamlessly, and don't require paying monthly fees forever to listen to their own music. And pre-announcing a product without pricing, availability, and actual services is just a waste of a press release.
...
Microsoft may have thought it needed to do this announcement to respond to Steve Jobs' event this week and staunch the new flood of iPod sales. But if Microsoft thought they were going to spoil Apple's biggest iPod Christmas ever, it just threw away one of its chances to do so.

Microsoft's J Allard talks to Gizmodo:

The wrong consumer to start with is ... the one who says "You'll take my ipod from my cold clammy hands." People love their social networks, though. If they're over email, IM, or on the web, it's integrated into their lives. We want to bring that to portable music. Digital music is far front done. Ipod is the Pong of digital music. Let's take it to the next level. And connected is what its all about. The other thing is video. It's a much more inclusive part of people's life. Especially tail end video [referring to Wired and Chris Anderson's Long Tail theories]. How do we bring that to pockets? Oh yes: People said we want a bigger screen [than the ipod].
...
New Zune devices will come. They'll be fun, they'll be exciting. But like Xbox, we're going to keep adding features to the core idea. We're just scratching the surface with the WiFi and peer-to-peer connectivity. Put WiFi in, start with one or two scenarios that users will understand. A few times a year, we'll update the firmware, and let consumers do new and exciting things.

Meanwhile, Apple Insider has pictures of the new iPod Nano packaging:

The new second-gen iPod nanos began arriving in the United States in somewhat limited quantities on Wednesday. Each new nano ships in a completely translucent, hard plastic container that elegantly showcases the player while neatly tucking away the few accessories it includes. Along with the iPod, Apple packs a pair of headphones, an accessory adapter, USB cable and iPod nano Quick Start booklet. The player no longer ships with a protective sleeve.

Although the new nano is precisely the same height and width of its predecessor, Apple has conveniently (for its margins) offset the dock connector by about a millimeter, making the new nano completely incompatible with the first-generation iPod nano dock. Similarly, users will also have to plunk down extra change for a new pair of iPod nano lanyard head phones -- the new nano's headphone jack is spaced further away from the dock connector. 

Jeremy Horwitz answers FAQs about the new iPod range:

At 1.07” by 1.62” by 0.41” and 0.55 ounces, the iPod shuffle has changed the most dramatically from its 3.3” by 0.98” by 0.33”, 0.78 ounce predecessor. It is like an aluminum-clad version of the iPod Radio Remote, and only as much thicker as the added aluminum would suggest ... it is less than half the height of the old iPod shuffle and only a little wider; most of its body is thinner than the shuffle, but with the clip on the back it’s comparable.
...
Apple now sells the iPod nano in five colors - silver is the only color available for the 2GB iPod nano, while silver, pink, green, and blue are all 4GB colors, and black is the only color available for the 8GB iPod nano.
...
Those new Apple pack-in earphones [are] not as iconic as the past iPod earbuds, and will most certainly “blend in” a lot more with the crowd. But they sound good, feel noticeably lighter and softer in your ears, and preserve the best other features of Apple’s prior pack-ins: good sound, tiny headphone port plug, integrated length manager after the Y-splitter, and two-tone (white and gray) styling.
...
iPod nano now runs for 24 hours on a single charge, versus 14 hours for the prior model.
...
By storage capacity standards, the 80GB iPod is the best value in iPod history - under $4.50 per Gigabyte, and the cheapest top-of-line iPod Apple has ever introduced. Even the 1GB shuffle is only slightly more expensive than the now discontinued $69 512MB iPod shuffle.

Buffer overflow:

Around the Net

Around Computerworld

And finally... Vital cookie dunking statistics [yes, a cookie's a "biscuit" in Britain]

Richi Jennings is an independent technology and marketing consultant, specializing in email, blogging, Linux, and computer security. A 20 year, cross-functional IT veteran, he is also an analyst at Ferris Research. Contact Richi at blogwatch@richi.co.uk.

What People Are Saying

you all seem to forget that

you all seem to forget that 1.0 iPods were utter crap. No backlight, and it basically looked like a Gameboy with a scroll wheel. with no touch sensitivity either. an actual wheel. i'd say microsoft has done okay with the Zune's first release. if you're that picky, buy an iPod or wait for future generations of the zune and stop crapping on people who like something different than you.

furthermore, if you think any software or hardware comes out bug-free, you're an idiot. the hardest part of software/hardware marketing is getting the damn thing on shelves for people to buy. Patches for anything almost immediately come out days after the release of anything because there are people constantly working on bugs, glitches or whatever. microsoft's Zune will be a major competitor against the iPod, their just playing it safe and taking baby steps to get there. not unlike a lot of independent software developers today.

ZUNE ROCKS! APPlE IS 0k But

ZUNE ROCKS! APPlE IS 0k But only because you can buy vidoes of of itunes and i hate the ipod video becuase the outershell gets a scap on it from being in your pocket, YA THAT SUCKS. but you dont care ipod fans, you can just keep droning on about how ipod sucks, woops i mean rocks, while everyone puts there zune earphones on.

ZUNE ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

who cares its a MP3 player a

who cares its a MP3 player a freakin mp3 player but no i have to ge my little stupid ipod and it has 2 be perfect or i have to report all my little whoes on the web

oh ya ZUNE ROCKS iPod fangirls give up.
i do think mac makes better computers though

I forgot to mention this:

I forgot to mention this: that MP3/MP4 players should focus more in adding a Bluetooth Opt instead of an FM Radio?!! I mean which opt would you rather have in your MP3/MP4 player anyway? Is there really a comparison here or what? Lol.

***BLUETOOTH!!! BLUETOOTH!!! BLUETOOTH... that's all I have to say to all the MP3/MP4 player inventors - both IPOD & ZUNE_HELLOOOO!!!

Lets make it short... ZUNE

Lets make it short... ZUNE SUX & IPOD RULES!!! C'mon now, you really cares about listening to radios nowadays whilte you can make your own playlists of songs you organized that fits your mood. Why make it complicated for everyone to use while Ipod can be used even as young as an 10 year old which I'm speaking of my baby girl who got a 30gig. She fell in love with it and can even d/l her own movies in it. I got an 80gig, although I bought a Zune along with it for comparison. Zune may have a bigger screen but the pixel suz. Its just stretched version of the MP4 for Ipod and its not as sharp. Plus, they put Britney Murphy's video as a sample? Talking about bad advertisements - must be the reason why Zune didn't sell out well last holidays lol. The worst part is yet to come. I have an HP Media Center(w/WinXP-2)and I had 3 other HP PCs - 1 of them was a laptop. I followed the instructions for d/l and guess what? It kept giving the error warning - IN ALL PCs/LT. None would accept the program and I even tried the net d/l. I was like, ZUNE SUX!!! I even went to Best Buy and asked the GeekSquad to do it for me_ yeah, for a price of $199 in which I could afford to give someone an Ipod as a gift for the holiday with that price, don't you think? With Ipod, even before you own it_ you already have Itune the moment you purchased any PC/LT. Its worldwide because PCs/LT are distributed WORLDWIDE and you can put your own d/ls you have in your hard drive, not just songs but movies, too. All I can say is, the MP3 players are supposed to be portable and simple - who is stupid enough to stop jogging or whatever they are working out with just to send a song to someone you know that has a Zune like yours? While you can just wave your hands while enjoying the music you're listening and once you are done with whatever you're doing, just give your friend a call or email him/her the songs or song infos/links you want to share with him/her lol. Or you can text them about the cool song you were listening that you may think your buddy will be interested in with your cell phone cuz you still need a cell phone with your Zune or Ipod you know lol. Its just funny how Zune came about last holidays and totally a turn-off. The only way I would probably purchase Zune is, if Apple decided to end the Ipod line for good in which is never gonna happen lol. To all the Zune owners, I really hope Microsoft can prove us wrong someday_ NOT!!! Its just not going to happen lol. This is rediculous... I can't stop LOL_lol.

It's always amusing to watch

It's always amusing to watch elitist Apple nerds attack people who don't accept anything made by Apple as the lord and savior. They act like paranoid schizophrenics with their references to Microsoft being an "evil empire" and such. All you're doing is spewing your insecurities all over the place. You idiots are zealous because you use things made by a company that doesn't generally dominate the market. Nobody cares to hear you yelling, as all you're doing is making a fool out of yourself.

I don't think I need to explain all the problems iPods have. I'll sum them up into one: they break ALL THE TIME. That's it. That's all I ever hear about them. Everyone I talk to who has an iPod tells me it's broken or doesn't work properly. One guy told me his broke within the first week after he bought it. I don't worship Microsoft like you guys do with Apple. I didn't buy the Zune because it was made by Microsoft, I bought it because it wasn't an iPod. And you know what? It works great. Hasn't had a single problem yet. Whenever I walk into Best Buy, all I see in the customer service section is people explaining that their iPods are broken. There hasn't been a single day I've gone there when I haven't seen this. It's kind of depressing.

I don't love Microsoft, and I'm no fan of Apple. I don't let big corporations and their products control me like some brainwashing cult. I had a simple, logical thought process: iPods break all the time, but I want an MP3 player, so I'll get something OTHER than an iPod. My decision has worked so far. I seem to be the only person with an MP3 player I know who isn't complaining.

Now that I know about Microsoft's plans to update the firmware and expand on the wireless technology, I can see the Zune has much more potential than the iPod. The only way the iPod seems to have improved is their numbers get bigger (size but also price, and they repackage the old ones to look prettier, but they still break all the time, so what's the point? If you want to keep buying a new iPod every year, go ahead, but I'm happy with my not-broken Zune.

How can anyone not undstand

How can anyone not undstand how wireless is going to be the future of ANY device with data on it? How could any say they don't want wireless on an MP3 player, thats like saying wireless phones serve no purpose, the technologhy is new and simple minded people who buy apple products can't understand the bigger picture of product development.

A friend came back to Mexico

A friend came back to Mexico after a vacation on California and brought the brand new 30 GB Zune, but the software never worked on his Spanish Windows XP Operating system. Looking over the web I notice only English version is supported, not even Vista is supported. I can not understand why on a country with a big Hispanic community the language is not supported. Of course iPod + iTunes work fine no matter the language. The race is starting but MS is starting with the left foot.

thats because it was the

thats because it was the only thing out there any good, no one else had thought of the idea and now microsofts competing and your all afraid.

Haha... so funny -- taber

Haha... so funny -- taber tell us what you think once you actually get off Microsoft's payroll! It seems that MS has to plant fake reviews on all these blogs just to create some superficial aura of usability.

Isn't if funny how everone is saying: "oh yeah, come on, give MS a break, it is a 1.0 release product after all" -- the MS community EXPECTS things not to work from Day 1... don't forget, you're all paying the same good money for a crappy product, don't you think they should get it right from the start? I can't ever remember anyone ever defending Apple with an "it's only a 1.0 product" line before!

Pathetic job Microsoft... for the world's No.1 software company to do such a botch job of the software interface... you should be ashamed of yourselves!
Spend some of those wasted marketing dollars on research and development in future.