Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Sound Off's picture
Sound Off

From Computerworld Readers

Is the Mac a "viable alternative for real people with real jobs"?

Computerworld's Online Editorial Director Scot Finnie recently started using a MacBook Pro for his main work computer, in order to determine if it's a "viable alternative for real people with real jobs." Have you recently switched from Windows to a Mac at work? Was it a smooth experience, or were there hiccups? Share your thoughts below.

What People Are Saying

excavates eightieth meadows

excavates eightieth meadows twelves redesigned!accelerating laming ark brags

PC VS MAC AT WORK

I have been a mac user since day one . When it comes to comparing apples and bananas I always pick apples . but in a perfect world i would need a computer that works and that could run OS 10 and Windows and guess what my IMAC can do just that . What i am not sure of is if a PC could run OS 10 ...Would i have bought one ?

By the way one of my good friends works for a big advertising agency in NYC and told me they actually designed the Thinkpad campain on a Mac. So I guess its just a matter of taste .

Im a videomaker, and work

Im a videomaker, and work with 2 iMacs and a MacBook pro (for presentations with clients and "On fly" mastering). I dont know other way to make my proyects. Its affordable, its professional, its ok. With the rights plugins, and 3rd party software I'm ready to the real world. Really. I would like to have a mac pro too. Soon guys, soon. The mac values every dollar that they cost.
Right, I need to improve my english. Cheers from México.

My Client's Comment Summarizes it Nicely

I can't think of a better way to answer this question than one of my clients. I work at a computer services consulting firm, where we provide service to clients on pretty much any platform. One of our best clients is a die-hard Mac user; it's the only platform he's ever used, and as far as he's concerned, it's all he'll ever need. But his last Mac Book Pro was getting along in years, so he decided to buy something a little newer and flashier (actually, it looked pretty much the same to me, evidently they haven't changed much in the past 6 years or so). He bought a brand new 17" with a Core 2 Duo, and our next meeting, he was all excited and told us,

"This is the best Mac I've ever owned! I can run Windows on it!"

After all these years, he's finally found a way to be able to access all the non-Mac accessible content he's been without, such as the advanced statistical analysis software he had been accessing through Terminal Services for the past 15 years.

So, for some fields, a Mac may be fine, and for other people, maybe they can afford to pay double for the same hardware and to maintain 2 operating systems. But, for most of the "Real Jobs" and "Real People" out there, I would say the highest productivity for the cost is definitely sticking with Windows, since you'll probably end up running it anyways.

You need look no further

You need look no further than the Java enterprise development community. Attend any conference such as JavaOne, NoFluffJustStuff, The Spring Experiance....nearly 50% of all the laptops you see are MacBook's and MacBook Pro's ...and those presenting...the best and the brightest of the community...I'd venture to say that more than 75% are Mac users and do their presentations with their Mac laptops.

I can do my work perfectly

I can do my work perfectly with my macbook pro and the .mac agenda sharing with my collegeas. ichat is also a good alternative for skype and I really like the remote screen sharing functionality in leopard.

I only lack openworkbench as a suitable project planning tool, the finder is slow compared to the raw power of the file explorer and the microsoft tooling on a mac is really slow

Real Jobs

I find it to be quite annoying to hear a quote that would insinuate that persons who use macs are not "real people" and are without "real jobs." It is now commonplace for major universities, doctors of all disciplines, and other very specialized professions to not only use macs, but live by them. Some of these careers are far more demanding and advanced than those "real" positions in life. The reality is that for a computer to allow any type of lifestyle, profession, and generation or age to conveniently use its native os and incorporate any other os is simply amazing. I think the average real person could appreciate that, and the resentment is quite real on both sides of the fence. Mac users resent all the things that seem to drool from the mouths of the naive, yet we love to be the center of attention that revolves around all the products us non-real people use. I guess someone has to man the helm of the flagship so that everyone else has an idea of what they could be doing themselves. Macs are for leaders, thinkers, lovers of life, and real people! They just may not be for you!

Do what you like

I'm certainly a Mac addict - but if you like Windows, hey, stick with it. It keeps folks like me happy with less spyware, virus problems, etc. LOL!

I love my Mac, especially now that I can have both a Mac and Windoze on one laptop. I have the best of both worlds at my fingertips. We need both platforms though - competition is good for both of them.

So - do what you like!

I am working on macs since

I am working on macs since 1984, and I have to admit I rarely worked on pcs. So I can't really compare. The few times I had to use pcs I didn't really like them.

For almost one year now I am working with a friend in his real estate business. His company is based on a pc network (with linux servers). I told him I'wouldn't switch and continue using my mac. Networking is no problem at all, file servers and printers are easy to access, except for 2 weeks after installing OS X 10.5.0. Samba server could not be accessed until the problem was fixed with 10.5.1.

People at the office liked the design of my mac and after a couple of month all the pcs where replaced by...imacs but booted under XP. The boss told me it was for design reasons only, but it was out of question to skip the OS too.

I installed parallels on the conference mac mini in order to make the usual powerpoint presentations under XP as well as open up original CAD drawings with Vectorworks. People played arround with it during of times and last week the boss decided to switch to ....

...Leopard.

Grass is green on both sides...

After having had three PC computers I am going to buy myself a MAC [desktop] quite soon to use (purely) at home. However, I'll keep my current Windows based laptop just in case. To be perfectly honest what I think that both Apple and PC are equally good and it's up to you what you choose. When it comes to my work - our company uses Windows but I will be equally comfortable with using Mac at home - I had the chance to use Apple computers a few times and simply feel like having one. So - choose whatever you think works for you and remember that you can always switch back to PC if you feel the need to or buy a Mac next time you change your computer. No one forces you to buy either a PC or a Mac - it's totally up to you. Just like with cars - some prefer to drive a Porsche/Bentley/Maybach and some are big fans of '76 Ford Mustang or Dodge Challenger:-)It's a matter of preference...and style

PS - Note however, it is said that even the Devil himself works on Windows;-) Not quite sure what they're using in Heaven though