Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Kevin OKeefe's picture
Kevin OKeefe

From the Trenches

Network management: a profession, not a hobby

With the proliferation of computers, inexpensive wireless routers, and plug n' play hardware nowadays, many homes are operating with small networks.  Behind some of these home networks lies a newbie, a possible future techie in training, and from that ever increasing pool of applicants spawn what I like to call the "professional hobbyist".  A lot of the unnecessary work that I come across in the field today is the result of people who have little to no work experience, no education, and certainly no professional certifications in the field of network administration, performing network administrative tasks.  Just because someone can unbox & plug in a wireless router (security risks and all) doesn't make them an expert in the field of wireless networks.  This is usually where the average, everyday citizen takes their first steps to becoming a "professional hobbyist" (PH).  These first initial steps then foster the belief that the PH knows all about the complexities of installing & configuring a network, and can take this knowledge with them to the corporate world and make some money.  

Unfortunately, the fish don't jump right in the boat ... There are the fisherman (the PH), and then there are the fish, the unfortunate companies who succumb and take the bait ... The lure of getting a lot and spending very little.  When has this ever been the case?  When will people and companies finally come to terms and figure this out?  The Golden Rule in Information Technology should be "You get what you pay for".  This includes both the purchasing of hardware as well as network administrative services.  Whether the company can afford to keep a dedicated network manager on staff, or if the company retains the services of a network consultant, these individuals should be qualified.  But I continue to see this happen every day at an overwhelmingly high rate.  Small companies looking to save a buck, many of these companies never even having an IT budget in place, who unwittingly retain the services of these professional hobbyists (PH).

In my experiences, the story usually starts one of two ways: "The Apocalyptic Referral" or "The Trojan Horse".  The former starts out with the PH getting their foot in the door with the "I know a guy" referral from someone who works for the company.  The latter occurs when someone on the inside takes over the network admin role, either being assigned the role by the company or by slipping in to the role on their own being the "resident techie".  "The Trojan Horse" is usually the more common method, and more catastrophic to a business network.  The PH in this case takes the ball and runs with the new IT role in hopes of padding the ‘ole resume, and proceeds to use the company's network as their own private "test lab", a technical playground that he/she hopes to learn from.  All good things (in this case not a "good thing") come to and end, and the company receives the final blow when this person decides to leave for greener pastures, and in their wake leaves a "less then perfect" (shall we say) network, one that Dr. Frankenstein would be very proud of ... Only Dr. Frankenstein knowing how everything is "pieced" together.

As with everything else in life, you get what you pay for.  By writing this article, I hope to warn small businesses from this fate, as well as to prevent some hobbyists from biting off more then they can chew with the "baptism by fire" approach to jumpstarting a new career for themselves.  All businesses must come to terms that they require someone who is knowledgeable and educated in the field of network administration to manage their network resources.  Information is one of, if not the greatest asset a company has, and that asset is stored on servers that should be properly maintained & protected.  Time & time again, I explain to companies that it costs more to clean up the damage after it has occurred, not to mention the loss of time in business productivity, rather then simply spending the money up front to have a true professional manage your network.  Unfortunately for them, not all companies heed this advice.

Beware of the "professional hobbyist" ... Hopefully not coming to a network near you ...  

What People Are Saying

Kevin sounds like he busted

Kevin sounds like he busted his rear to get where he is and he makes good points. But, people have to start somewhere. Not everyones daddy owns a company with an IT Dept. I was a professional hobbyist when I got the Trojan Horse job paying 60 grand a year and I held on to it for all of nine months until I decided that I needed a degree from college to continue doing this. That's my opportunity cost - leaving the job to pursue the piece of paper. I will graduate in May. I currently volunteer my services in various disciplines and some of them even pay me to do it. If I had not been a PH first, I probably wouldn't have garnered much interest in becoming a "real IT Pro". I'm just saying that not everyone with no certifications or job experience don't have the skills required, because a lot of them are quite good and there are also a lot of bad apples. Cheers

I agree with your analysis

I agree with your analysis of my article Eddie, but don't get me wrong, we all begin somewhere. There's a fine line between the "Professional Hobbyist", and the "baptism by fire" approach to learning & getting your feet wet in the filed of Information Technology. According to your response, you appear like someone who has the "measure twice and cut once" approach, which I always adhered to when I was starting out. I would always post questions to those who were more knowledgeable then me (colleagues, newsgroups, etc.) on how they would proceed with an IT task, learn from their experience, and why they did what they did, and then apply it in my specific case. The type of individual who becomes the PH, is the person who thinks they know it all, and unfortuantely become "humbled" by issues caused by jumping head first in to a task, without the necessary planning & consideration in advance. In these cases, the company suffers, and the "PH" gains wisdom at their expense. Don't get me wrong, I deal a lot with the company's onsite employees that are considered the "on site techie go-to-person", and those people I commend for asking for my advice prior to jumping in to the fire (so to speak). We all start somewhere, we just have to learn from other people's mistakes when we can. No one knows it all...

Kevin, Your comments are

Kevin,
Your comments are spot-on, and relate directly to one of my everlasting pet peeves about how companies treat their IT resources. Short-sighted cost-cutting, choosing the lowest bidder, not investing in training of employees, all lead to the sorry state of not just network administration, but configuration management, security, application development, and any other IT discipline you can name. It's the Wal-Mart mentality, and causes long lasting suffering in nearly every company I have seen. We should never accept second-rate expertise for the sake of expedience.