Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


David Haskin's picture
David Haskin

Global Mobile

Why Apple TV is more important than iPhone

Apple could unleash Apple TV this week, and this device, not the iPhone, could become the most important Apple product launch since the original iPod.

That's because the stakes are much, much higher for Apple TV than iPhone. If iPhone succeeds, it will bring lots of revenue into Apple, but it basically is just an iPod with phone capabilities and a unique user interface. Apple TV, however, could open a whole new market for Apple and also has the potential to bring Internet distribution of movies and television into the mainstream.

Apple TV will connect computers to televisions. In other words, you can download movies and television programs to Apple TV, which can manage the media and distribute it to televisions throughout the house. Plenty of products with similar aspirations have failed, but this is Apple, after all. It not only has the ability to market the bejeebers out of Apple TV, but it also is likely to make it simple enough that even technical neophytes can set it up and use it and useful enough that everybody will love it.

If Apple TV succeeds, it could revolutionize digital media in general the same way iPod revolutionized digital music. There were plenty of media players before iPod was released, but it took Apple to make it work. Now, downloading music and playing it on a mobile device is so common that the idea barely is discussed anymore.

But times are different now and that is one reason that Apple TV could fail. IPod has been a success both because of and in spite of the fact that it works only in a closed system with iTunes. Being tied to iTunes worked when iPod was introduced because it greatly simplified the act of acquiring music online. That was despite the fact that users were tied to a single online music store, which made it difficult for other vendors to create competing online music stores.

But iTunes was started at a time when there really wasn't any serious legal competition for online music distribution. Now, however, there are plenty of sources of downloadable films and TV shows. Yet, Apple is insisting that Apple TV be tied only to iTunes. With all the other options available, Apple, for all its prowess at creating fierce customer loyalty, may not be able to make Apple TV work. Suddenly, closed distribution may work against, not for, Apple TV.

If Apple succeeds, Apple TV could do for moving pictures what iPod/iTunes did for music. That would make Apple both the most successful hardware maker and online media distributor. But the attempt also shines a light on Apple's my-way-or-the-highway approach to customer loyalty. So far, that approach has succeeded. This time, things could be different.

What People Are Saying

Xilisoft MP4 Converter is a

Xilisoft MP4 Converter is a powerful MP4 video conversion tool. It is capable of converting popular video files such as AVI, MPEG, DivX, MOV, RM, WMV, 3GP, VOB, VCD, DV to MP4 (MPEG4), Xvid, and converting audio files to MP3, AAC, M4A easily and fast.

www.mobile-video-converter.com/mp4-to-mobile

Yeah that's a great idea

Yeah that's a great idea apple!!!Too
----
Best Films Download

buy dvd movies online is a

buy dvd movies online is a way better site

If Apple succeeds, Apple TV

If Apple succeeds, Apple TV could do for moving pictures what iPod/iTunes did for music.

http://www.apple-tv-converter.net/

Flash to apple tv guide

Apple TV disappoints First,

Apple TV disappoints
First, Apple TV delivers very poor video quality using compressed mpeg4 files that is not even up to VHS standards. Huge step backward from HiDef TV. Tack on expensive and tedious downloads, and the fact that it's more expensive than better quality alternatives. Only a fool would buy Apple TV online without comparing it in the store next to the signal coming back from a (cheaper, faster, better) hi-def video recorder like Tivo.

The fact that they blatantly buy time to be featured as "news" on CNN, MSNBC, Good Morning America, etc. (that's called "payola") goes on to prove that this greedy DRM corporate monster is no longer the warm fuzzy Mac company we grew up with.

Apple TV is limited to 720P

Apple TV is limited to 720P resolution, which means it's a non-starter from the get-go.

Why Apple didn't make sure that their HD product was 1080i, bewilders me.

As good as their designers are (yeah, I admit it), this is a HUGE mistake.

Yes, most existing HD TVs are only capable of 720P, however, most new HD TVs are natively capable of 1080i.

1080i is on the extreme &

1080i is on the extreme & expensive fringe, and the file size alone makes it only good for the future, not for the next 5 years or so.

720p is PLENTY of resolution, 85% of sets sold are 720p or lower, 98% of content is 720p or lower, so it's not an issue today, tomorrow or five years from now.

And don't you think there will be a new model by then? :)

sorry, folks... huge pet

sorry, folks... huge pet peeve of mine, ppl not knowing to not follow "reason" with "why". if yours is typographical errors, i can take that. i actually had a positive apple experience a few months ago(or more, you guys'd prolly know) over this very issue. apple.com at the time had a link (i believe) to a page discussing (listing) the top reasons "why" a person should switch to apple ("buy a mac"??). anyway, i called apple on it, and they changed it. if i recall, they were near the end of that campaign anyway, so the version with the word "why" omitted wasn't up very long. as to fiscal, i submit from dictionary.com: "fiscal... 2. of or pertaining to financial matters in general." if it doesn't strike you that purchasing and promoting ms products pertain to ms' financial matters, i am happy to agree to disagree. well, i just learned my mom's cancer has been complicated with pneumonia, so i'm not in the mood to get back on topic right now.

At

At LivingRoomConvergence.com, we think that the Apple TV is really going to be huge. The convergence between the home entertainment center and computers cannot be denied and the Apple TV is certainly one of the first major steps in making this new area of technology accessible to almost everyone.

Personally, I applaud Apple for their foresight with the Apple TV. I think this product will become HUGE.

I'm not that fussed. I

I'm not that fussed. I already get digital TV, DRV, and internet video together in one device because the device is an iMac. I expect it amounts to the same thing as Apple TV, minus a giant TV display.

How is it? A lot of internet video is Flash, which tends to be crap. Often you can't download a file, nor blow it up to full screen. Overall, not a good situation. If you can't download it's useless, and I can't see how you're gonna get it on your Apple TV.

Video podcasting can sometimes be good. It certainly gives the viewer more freedom to do what they want with the media. However, overall, the lack of standard file formats makes internet video today marginally worse than it was in 1996.

In general, it seems the video that one can buy on the net is grossly overpriced, particularly compared to commercial digital TV which is free.

And then there's DRM. iTunes DRM seems less restrictive than most, but after one round of dealing with authorizing computers for music, I'd had enough. Most of the other video downloads on the web seem to use some kind of Microsoft solution which means buying a new computer. They only work with MS Windows XP, MS Media Player 10, and depend on a proprietary MS video format. I don't imagine you'll be playing any of that on your Apple TV.

(Background: Mpeg4 is the new ISO standard for everything, like HD DVD, digital TV, 3G, etc. Files ending in ".mp4" are player independent; designed for internet users. Mp4 ends proprietary video formats which require users to maintain an array of players. At the same moment, MS drags proprietary formats back in on the back of DRM.)

After 4 or 5 years with this set up, I'm cancelling services like internet DVD rentals that are introducing DRM video downloads. I'm not buying. I don't plan on buying anything with DRM. My computer/TV lets me do anything I want with TV. It's all about DVD quality and it's free. I can't imagine why anyone would pay extra to be hobbled by DRM.

Granted, my situation is probably dependent on free-to-air digital TV. If I relied on cable, I'd be SOL.