Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Subscribe to our e-mail newsletters
For more info on a specific newsletter, click the title. Details will be displayed in a new window.
Computerworld Daily News (First Look and Wrap-Up)
Computerworld Blogs Newsletter
The Weekly Top 10
More E-Mail Newsletters 
Douglas Schweitzer's picture
Douglas Schweitzer

The Security Sector

Sad but true!

I'd like to add a little anecdote to this article about banning iPods in classrooms. When I was in college some years ago, we didn't have iPods or any other small digital devices with the potential to store information. One day, before an exam was to be given, I arrived to class a bit early to get in some more last minute studying. The student next to me also arrived early - only he had a different cramming method. His was to write as much potential test information right on his desk, but in an ancient language (which he spoke fluently but few people still use) hoping that the professor wouldn't catch him. (No need to identify the language.) Upon arriving to class, the first thing the professor did was to make everyone change their seats. It was the first time he'd had us do that - and I'm not sure what prompted it, nonetheless it was an effective strategy indeed!  I agree that the system rewards those of us who have great memorization skills. My teenaged son is one of those lucky dudes who can memorize material quickly and retain that info for many years (sometimes to his parents' chagrin). Once we get into the "real world" we tend to lookup the things we need and rely less on our ability to memorize.

What People Are Saying

Perhaps we should

Perhaps we should distinguish between what material is useful to memorize and what isn't. For example, I once had a physics teacher who would provide all the formulas for us during exams, and even let us have a small notecard to put notes on. But it was up to us to know how to use the formulas. He always said that memorizing formulas are a waste of time because they are easily accessible in the real world. The hard part, the part worth memorizing is the process of knowing how to use the formulas. But then I've had teachers who believe that knowing the formulas are a given when it comes to exams and laugh at the idea of providing formulas for students on an exam...

True, but the fundamental

True, but the fundamental concepts that one learns in most classes are basic to understanding the subject. Those who can accurately work from memory are quicker, more efficient, and more productive students, as well as workers. This skill can be developed through practice, and thus justifies closed-book testing.