Ads by TechWords
Subscribe to our e-mail newsletters
For more info on a specific newsletter, click the title. Details will be displayed in a new window.
Computerworld Daily News (First Look and Wrap-Up)
Computerworld Blogs Newsletter
The Weekly Top 10
More E-Mail Newsletters 
Preston Gralla's picture
Preston Gralla

Seeing Through Windows

Another anemic showing for U.S. broadband

If you need any more evidence that U.S. broadband is anemic at best, here's another one: The Communications Workers of America (CWA) has just released a report ranking us 16th in broadband speeds and connectivity among industrialized nations.

According to a Computerworld report, "the median real-time download speed in the U.S. is 1.9Mbit/sec., compared with 61Mbit/sec. in Japan, 45Mbit/sec. in South Korea, 17Mbit/sec. in France and 7Mbit/sec. in Canada."

Not only are our speeds pitifully slow, but we pay more for them. The Computerworld article notes that in Japan, people pay about $30 per month for 50Mbit/sec. access. By way of contrast, in the U.S., we pay $20 for about 1Mbit/sec. service and $30 to $40 for about 4Mbit/sec. service.

As I've previously written, we also lag the world when it comes to broadband penetration as well. We're a mediocre 24th in the world.

Congress may take action to improve on all that. Sen. Daniel Inouye (D-Hawaii) has introduced a bill to require that the federal government better track true broadband use, something the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has refused to do. That bill will only be the first step; next will come pressure to ensure better broadband access for all.

Other Blog Entries by Preston Gralla:

What People Are Saying

Rate this
Rated 0
272 Votes

Preston: good blog. You say,

Preston: good blog.

You say, 'According to a Computerworld report, "the median real-time download speed in the U.S. is 1.9Mbit/sec., compared with ,,,"'

It ain't a Computerworld report. It is a Computerworld article about a SpeedMatters.org report.

Please correct this. It is misleading.

Rate this
Rated +28
264 Votes

Um, please note that the US

Um, please note that the US is quite a bit larger than the other listed nations. Our infrastructure costs are therefore much higher.

(It still costs too much, though.)

Rate this
Rated -27
235 Votes

Much like the absence of

Much like the absence of universal health care, and the lack of an effective public education system, the US brings up the rear of the industrialized world on the broadband front. On the other hand, we're at the top of the third-world dung pile. Thanks, Free-Trade Republicans.

Rate this
Rated +28
268 Votes

Yeah, no mention of the

Yeah, no mention of the Verizon Fios. I use that. It's great. Ive had no problem with it in 6 months, and it's fairly peppy. The windows TCP stack slows me down more than my broadband does now.

Rate this
Rated +20
272 Votes

I'm sorry. I simply fail to

I'm sorry. I simply fail to see why it is the federal government's job to provide us with a better median real-time download speed ranking.

Rate this
Rated -27
255 Votes

The CWA is not a government

The CWA is not a government agency. Additionally, telecommunications is vital to any first world nation's prosperity and should be monitored closely.

Rate this
Rated -10
282 Votes

Well, I think that our

Well, I think that our current fiber backbone has more than enough capacity. But after 9/11 etc telecoms started flooding the market. That was the birth of 1cent phone calls to the UK and companies like vonage starting putting the pinch down.

Simple economic manipulation affects us all. They keep the supply low so we continue to pay premium prices.

The joke is on us. We should really pressure companies like verizon to get off their rears and put the money they spend lobbying congress into upgrading services.

Rate this
Rated -3
209 Votes

What's worse is even with

What's worse is even with the lack of speed, the service quality and reliability has been horrible. One large provider that I am currently using has had an issue with their "line tap" for well over 6 months. Repeated calls and live chat sessions end with the same. Unplug the cable modem to reset it, unhook all PCs from the small network and hook my PC directly to the modem after unhooking my wireless router. Then they send a technician out that says there is a problem with the line at the pole and they will do a line dispatch, it will take about 2-4 days for that to happen. All works for 1-3 days, then it dumps again. I did actually get reimbursed for one month of service, but at $49.95/mo for a 6Mb line that runs at best 700-800K any given evening, and 1.2-1.8Mb at 3AM it's poor service, poor quality and high prices that are the epitome of US broadband service.