Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Martin McKeay's picture
Martin McKeay

Security Matters

Was the iPhone ready for prime time?

I'll admit freely that I'm a little jealous of people who have iPhones; I want one for myself just because they're so new, so pretty and shiny.  But even if I could afford one right now, I doubt I'd pick one up.  Between of the problems with Safari and the efforts being made to attack the phone by anyone looking to make a name for themselves, the security on the iPhones is going to be more than a little questionable for the next few months.  Given that the latest set of vulnerabilities discovered can lead to full control over the iPhone, I'm doubly glad I haven't purchased one.

I'm not one of those people who put their entire lives in their cell phone.  To be honest, I barely use my cell phone's capabilities beyond being an address book and connecting to my laptop to the Internet while on the road.  I personally don't see much common sense in putting major portions of my digital life into a device I could easily lose in a cab or drop in a toilet (don't laugh, I can't be the only one to have done that).  But I know other people who rely on their phone more than they do their laptop or desktop, which makes any vulnerability in the phone software doubly important to them.

When the beta for Safari was released it only took security researchers a few hours to find vulnerabilities.  While the version of Safari on the iPhone seems to be a little more secure, the fact that a link on a malicious web site can cause the iPhone to dial out is a serious concern.  I'm sure Apple is doing everything they can to fix these holes, but I wish they'd done their beta testing before releasing the iPhone, rather than letting their customers do it for them. 

If you own an iPhone, be very careful about what you put on it.  I suspect that we're just seeing the tip of the iceberg concerning the vulnerabilities to be found in the iPhone.  It's the hottest thing in the mobile phone market, everyone who has one wants to use all it's capabilities, and it's untested.  All of these make it a very ripe target for malicious activity, so expect a lot of patching in the foreseeable future.  I just hope the patches don't lead to problems of their own.

What People Are Saying

LOL, so you buy devices

LOL, so you buy devices while Apple customers buy toys...how condescending. They called the first Mac a toy because it used a mouse. Then it took MS about 13 years to emulate the toy.

Yes Podcasting has advanced computing. Computing is more than just spreadsheets, databases and word processing. It's also about information retrieval. Podcasting offers a new way of using computers to retrieve information and put it on portable devices, making the process almost entirely automatic. Almost every website that offers information now offers Podcasts. You can be as stubborn as you like, but don't be an idiot.

Yes, Linux might outsell Mac OS within a year. So what! There will always be a market for low end computers and with MS Vista, window users will no longer have a low end option. Linux will expand at Microsoft's expense, not Apple's. Apple will continue to increase the number of computers they sell each year and make huge profits, just as they've done for the last 5 years running.

Yes, there was a point 10 years ago where the future of Apple was in grave doubt. And Microsoft did help them out tremendously by promising to develop future versions of MS Office for the Mac. But that was then and this is now. The Apple customer base is growing and they are more satisfied and show more brand loyalty than any other customer base. Let me give you a clue... It's not only about market share, it's mostly about profits. And for the past couple of years, Apple outperforming Dell and HP.

I think your predictions are more based on wishful thinking rather than any kind of factual analysis.

Feign wrote "I cannot - for

Feign wrote "I cannot - for the life of me - understand why anyone in their right mind would spend $600.00 for a telephone!"

Because it's not just a telephone, it's a great mp3 player, video player, web browser all rolled into one. If you did a little research, you'll find some other smartphones costing as much if not higher.

Feign wrote "The iPhone is not going to change the world in any way. It's not going to advance computing anymore than the iPod has - (i.e. not at all)."

LOL, guess you never heard the term "PodCast"? Just because you're not participating in the latest computing trends doesn't mean they don't exist.

Feign wrote "Apple has simply stopped trying to compete in the computer arena"

Did you see Apple's quarterly results reported today? While the media only talks about the iPod and iPhone, Apple sold more computers this quarter than any other in it's history. They will never threaten the Windows monopoly, but they will continue to sell high quality computers while they branch out into consumer electronics.

Can you say "fart" on

Can you say "fart" on ComputerWorld????

I cannot - for the life of

I cannot - for the life of me - understand why anyone in their right mind would spend $600.00 for a telephone! I do understand the (maybe universal) desire to have the newest, coolest toys around, but to be f'd in the a to get one? Come on let's get serious. The iPhone is not going to change the world in any way. It's not going to advance computing anymore than the iPod has - (i.e. not at all). Apple has simply stopped trying to compete in the computer arena - it's seen that Linux installations will soon relegate it and it's archaic marketing model (all proprietary, all the time) to 3rd place - and is reduced to producing toys - more power to them. But let's stop the slavering every time Jobs farts (Oh, such a wonderful fart!)

This sounds like FUD to me.

This sounds like FUD to me. Windows XP is still being patched, years after it's release. But you, who freely admits you don't keep sensitive information on your phone, are "doubly glad" you haven't purchased one? Are you going to wait until Windows XP is totally secure before using it? Here's a hint to all PC and iPhone users: Learn to recognize Phishing emails and delete them.

I agree with the above

I agree with the above comment. I seriously doubt other version 1.0 products have been without issues, some potentially serious. I have complete faith that Apple will soon correct the vulnerability issue, as well as others. I have had several "smart phones", most recently a Treo 650. You couldn't pay me to go back. And yes... I wrote this comment on my iPhone!

Please compare this to any

Please compare this to any other version 1.0 of an advanced technology you are aware of.

I've had an iPhone since

I've had an iPhone since they went on sale, and apart from an occasional Safari crash (not phone crash), everything seems solid (hardware and software). I haven't thought of too many "they better fix thats" and the overall phone is so much less frustrating than any previous phone I've owned, that I don't think people need to wait for V2. Just my opinion.

Your comment "apart from an

Your comment "apart from an occasional Safari crash (not phone crash), everything seems solid" highlights one of the most used vectors in hacking, buffer overflows which can and often do result in the application crashing and resultant code being excuted immediately after.
So the next time Safari crashes on you in the back of your mind you had better start wondering if that was just a minor glitch or someone's code entering your device.

Doesn't sound as though

Doesn't sound as though you'll have to wait long before a second generation iPhone hits the market.