Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Preston Gralla's picture
Preston Gralla

Seeing Through Windows

What Microsoft doesn't want you to know about Vista SP1

Microsoft touts performance and reliability as the key benefits of Vista's SP1, but a close look at the beta shows a significant change Microsoft doesn't seem to want you to know about --- you can now easily change your default desktop search tool to Google Desktop Search, or any another one.

As I point out in my review of the beta of SP1, SP1 makes several interface changes related to search. The Start menu's Search link has been taken away, and if you choose Start --> Default Programs --> Set your default program, you can easily change your default search to any tool you want. As I show in my review, there are several other changes related to search as well.

Those changes were not made willingly. Microsoft made them as an extension of the company's 2002 antitrust settlement with government regulators.

But in briefings Microsoft gave to the press, PointPoint presentations, and a white paper about SP1, Microsoft made no mention of the change, even though the company presented in exquisite detail many other much more minor changes that SP1 makes.

The reason is pretty clear: Google already owns Internet search. Microsoft worries that it could also own desktop search, which could cause serious problems for Microsoft.

But neglecting to tell people about one of the more significant changes SP1 makes isn't the way to combat Google. People are too smart for that --- they'll find out how to use an alternate desktop search on their own.

Ironically, Vista's built-in search is superior to Google Desktop Search --- Microsoft doesn't need to resort to these kinds of tactics in order to combat Google. Google Desktop Search treats your data as if it's Internet data; Vista's search treats it like it's desktop data. So the Vista search is far more flexible, and better integrated into the operating system. My guess is that most people won't make the move to Google Desktop Search, even when they find out how easy it is to switch.

Next time around, I hope Microsoft is more forthcoming about changes it makes to Windows. It doesn't need to rely on these kinds of tactics, particularly when in a case like this, its search beats the competition.

What People Are Saying

Neither could be worse than

Neither could be worse than XP Search, which has all the detection powers of a blind man stumbling around a desert looking for weapons of mass destruction.
Its so poor I never use it anymore, it never finds anything.
For example, I have around 10,000 jpg images on my laptop. If I search my C:\ for '*.jpg', XP finds zero files.

Vista SP1 = Special polished

Vista SP1 = Special polished turd

Desktop Search in its

Desktop Search in its various guises is no substitute for good organization on the user's part.

I personally would much rather see an improved file manager, along with a less messy file hiearchy. Adding 'My Documents' and hiding system files was a joke.

I guess the idea now is to never once have to crack open Windows Explorer, and just rely on desktop search. Devolution of the species, imo.

There are many who state

There are many who state that the vista search creates a multitude of problems giving erroneous results on things that have been deleted or moved arround, and whats worse it does not find new things that it should. Google desktop is far better and does not make many of these mistakes.
But both do slow down your system. As a power user I use the simple non index search and I just make sure I categorize my files in a logical way.

Like the other commenters

Like the other commenters had stated, Microsoft has been public with the search changes and why in other place beside the whitepaper. Preston Gralla needs to more research.

woauww. big secret this

woauww. big secret this is!!! you have a problem with MS not yelling that you can change their integrated search or what? it's marketing, it's lot of stuff behind all this. for a standard user who is searching for a picture or an audio, changing this would not make any difference. so why bother with it?

I virtually never need to

I virtually never need to use the search functions of Vista or XP. Most useless thing ever IMO.

I agree with Donny V !!!

I agree with Donny V !!! Preston obviously is not an official Vista SP1 tester, otherwise he would easily know about this change!!! This review was typical anti-Microsoft with no shred of proof!! The *BETA* SP1 documentation fully explains this change. Once Vista SP1 has been signed off, then the official public documentation will also include this information.

What happens when you press

What happens when you press F3 while on the desktop in Vista SP1 then?

This is not new. Anybody

This is not new. Anybody following SP1 or Microsoft would know about this change.

Research first...

And yes the built in search is way better than Googles.