Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Subscribe to our e-mail newsletters
For more info on a specific newsletter, click the title. Details will be displayed in a new window.
Computerworld Daily News (First Look and Wrap-Up)
Computerworld Blogs Newsletter
The Weekly Top 10
More E-Mail Newsletters 

Quest for a decent keyboard

There are more than a dozen keyboards available at my local Staples and none of them is worth a damn for a touch typist like me. Those who aren't old enough to have used an IBM Selectric typewriter or the first IBM PC keyboard don't know what a difference a good quality keyboard makes.

Those early devices had excellent keystroke travel and responded with satisfying mechanical clacking sound that told you the system had registered each keystroke.

Good keyboards can improve productivity and reduce stress on your hands. Unfortunately, today's keyboards are cheap, unresponsive, lightweight affairs with little or no tactile response. Keyboards are tacked onto computers almost as an afterthought. They have become the equivalent of the standard equipment AM radio that used to ship in American automobiles in the '70s. But while Detroit's choice of radios has improved a bit since then, keyboards have only gone downhill.

Most aftermarket units I've played with focus not on tactile quality but on adding buttons and features such as infrared or Bluethooth connections. Ergomics are limited to slanting the keys so that the user must assume a Yoga position to type on them.

I was sorely reminded of this situation when I ran across a CNET story on this topic today, Top 10 tech we miss. Number 7 on the list? Good keyboards. Fortunately, author Rafe Needleman says there is at least one company that still makes a top-notch keyboard: Unicomp. I think I'll have to get one.

What People Are Saying

I too agree with Robert, in

I too agree with Robert, in fact, I got here by searching Google for "quality tactile -membrane keyboard". The problem I've had over and over is that these cheap (or expensive Microsoft Natural) "membrane" switch keyboards end up with sticky Shift keys. It becomes a real pain when doing frequent remote control sessions requiring shortcut key combinations and entering passwords. Mac users seem to be enamored with the Matias Tactile Pro which uses Alps mechanical keyswitches - too bad it's only for Apple. As to T.R. Valentine's concern about a "clacky" keyboard, I agree also. The solution might be a tactile keyboard with mechanical switches that's quiet too. Anybody got a spare keyboard factory?

Quite a few of my friends,

Quite a few of my friends, myself included, shop for our keyboards at:

http://www.pckeyboard.com/

Unicomp makes a very good hybrid, reminiscent of the old IBM PC (model 80, I believe). They are heavy and have a wonderful tactile feedback but are not so loud as to give you a headache (at 90wpm).

Read the comment about

Read the comment about laptop keyboards. I don't know if the Dell XPS is any different but I have found it to be a nicer experiance than trying to use a desktop keyboard. Most of the current desktop keyboards are very slow(I do a lot of gaming) and I find them to be hard to type on. The laptop keyboard that I have is nice due to the fact that the keys are low profile allowing me to type faster with more accuracy. It also is quieter and very responsive. I have delt with laptop keyboards that are horrible, unresponsive, and not fun to use so I can see where you might have some problems.

I also appreciate good

I also appreciate good keyboards, but it no longer seems to matter. I can do OK on whatever Dell sends me now. But one thing I really miss is a keyboard with the function keys on the left so you could do the keyboard shortcuts with one hand. (Keyboard shortcuts? What are they? sigh. . .)

DK

I did a response post at

I did a response post at http://www.computerworld.com/blogs/node/748

Like Rob I'm a big fan of

Like Rob I'm a big fan of the old IBM Selectric keyboard. But Ms./Mr. Valentine's observation about noise is valid. I remember walking past typing pools (Remember them?) and some of the women (Almost all of the typists were women.) wore earmuffs. To get their attention, you had to walk in front of their clacking Selectrics and wave.

My current favorite keyboard for my Windows laptop is a wireless unit from Logitech. But the device is a commodity. I can't even find the model number. (Maybe it's the M/N Y-RH35. But who knows?) And Apple has finally produced a decent keyboard with its new iMacs. The Bluetooth wireless keyboard is very good, especially compared to the crappy units Apple used to build.

The worst keyboards imaginable, though, are those that are built-in to our laptops computers. They make any desktop keyboard a pleasure by comparison.

Here's interesting site that discusses keyboard alternatives.

Yes, but.... I also have a

Yes, but....

I also have a difficult time finding good keyboards -- but one user's preference is not anothers. For instance, I do NOT want a clacky keyboard because it makes too much noise (especially at 90+ wpm).

At present, I use a Micro$oft 'Natural Keyboard Pro'. It took a few days to become accustomed to the split ergonomic keyboard, but I now find it more comfortable than the old rectangular grid layout. I imagine it would be very annoying to users who do not touch type, but I touch type.

What I would like to find is an overlay (skin-type) for the various keyboards I use (US, US-International, Greek Polytonic). Now THAT is something difficult to find.

I totally agree. I used to

I totally agree. I used to have a old IBM keyboard that I liberated from a dumpster at a previous job. Now I use a superannuated Dell unit (AT102W).

This very topic was also discussed on this week's "This Week In Tech" podcast (episode 17). Summary: the key is the Alps switch as found in the Avant Stellar and Matias Tactile Pro.

richi.