Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Preston Gralla's picture
Preston Gralla

Seeing Through Windows

OpenOffice 3 review: Who needs Microsoft Office?

I've just put the beta of OpenOffice 3 through its paces, and found that the office suite can do just about anything that Microsoft Office can do, supports a wide variety of formats...and, of course, is free. Given all that, who needs Microsoft Office?

I reviewed the Windows version of OpenOffice 3. The 147.9 MB download comes with six applications: the Writer word processor, Calc spreadsheet, Impress presentations program, Base database program, Math equation editor, and Draw graphics program. Even at a more than 147 MB download, though, it's still svelte compared to Microsoft Office.

Keep in mind that this is an early beta, and the program isn't expected to be ready until September. It's buggy, so don't use it in a production environment.

For most of what you use an office suite for, you'll find that OpenOffice 3.0 will more than fill your needs. Whether you're creating documents, spreadsheets, or presentations, all the basics, and much more is here. There's excellent formatting tools, mail merge, macros, solid charting tools, and the ability to easily create presentations.

An excellent new addition is the Start Centre, pictured below. It lets you easily create a new document, or open an existing one --- just click the proper icon. The Start Centre only appears if you don't currently have an OpenOffice application opened. Once you've opened an application, you can create or open a document by right-clicking the OpenOffice icon in the system tray, and making the appropriate choice.

OpenOffice 3.0 Start Centre

Particularly useful is that OpenOffice now handles a wide variety of formats, including the upcoming OpenDocument Format (ODF) 1.2 standard, and will also be able to open documents created in Microsoft Office 2007 and Office 2008 for the Mac, which means that it's about as universally useful as an Office suite can be. It can also export files to PDF format. Mac users will be pleased to know that it can run on Mac OSX without having to use X11.

The OpenOffice wizards are especially useful, and walk you through tasks such as creating databases and presentations. Experts won't need them, but everyone else will most likely welcome then. You can see and Impress wizard in action below.

OpenOffice 3.0 Impress

One drawback is the program's stodgy, dull-looking overall interface. It's functional, but not more than that. And it's certainly not nearly as useful as the Microsoft Office 2007 ribbon. The screenshot below shows Writer in action. It's good that it now supports displaying multiple pages on screen. But overall, using this program feels like a trip back to the 1990s.

OpenOffice 3.0 Writer

OpenOffice also doesn't support some of Microsoft Office 2007's higher-end features, such as Quick Parts. And there's very few templates, backgrounds, and layouts. And if you work in an enterprise that's standardized on Microsoft Office, you won't find the program of much use.

But if you can live without a few high-end features that most people don't use, and don't mind not having plenty of templates, you'll find OpenOffice 3 a winner. There's no need to pay top dollar for an office suite, when there's a free one, just waiting to be downloaded.

By the way, I'll have a more complete review running in Computerworld soon.

For more details about the beta, and to download it, click here.

Like this blog? Subscribe to the RSS feed!

What People Are Saying

Using OO in online classes

Hi, all. I had a student a few terms ago (I teach online grad. classes in ancient history) who dropped tantalizing bits of information all term about why he didn't have a clue as to what was going on in class. I think that he said that he had Open Office at one point though I can't find the email. I have Office 2002 (or is it 2003? Don't know; don't really care).

He apparently couldn't open the syllabus to see what work was required over the 16-week term. And he apparently couldn't see(?) or at least access the other students' reports over the course of the term. And he didn't know that there was a midterm scheduled. Could he not see the .html announcement I put up every week with instructions for that week? Then he missed the final exam.
Does Open Office mean that he couldn't actually SEE any of my instructions for 16 weeks??

Perturbed Professor

Abusing OO in class

Generally, no, there shouldn't be any reasonable excuse for not being able to see content you created in Office. How well OO renders may depend on what kind of content, but unless he was using OpenOffice pre-1.0 and you were doing extreme gymnastics with obscure Office features it should have worked fine.

One wouldn't ordinarily view HTML with OO, but it is possible. (Did he know the purpose of a web browser?) So if your web pages weren't engaging in any proprietary, InternetExplorer-specific shenanigans then there's no reasonable excuse he could not see other students posts or your schedules. You might want to check with the school's web site administrators to find out how the web site system works. It could be doing Microsoft-specific things you don't realize.

Thank you very much. That's

Thank you very much. That's pretty much what I thought but wasn't sure.

Who needs Microsoft Office?

Who needs MS Office?
Anyone who wants to print documents correctly (even with an HP printer which OO supposedly works with).All my other applications print just fine but not OO.
Anyone who wants to share spreadsheets with users who have MS Office. Lots of financial & engineering functions created in MS office don't work in OO.
Anyone who wants to print labels. Many avery label templates don't work in OO.
Anyone who wants to share Power Point/Impress documents with MS Office users. The colors & some formatting do not display the same.
I keep running into more projects that are easy with MS Office but are time consuming or impossible in OO.
I have the default save settings set to MS format but it still doesn't help when trying to shar documents with others.

That's odd, I use OO on all

That's odd, I use OO on all the computers I support and have never had an issue.

The issue about file sharing between MS Office apps and OO is more about changing your default save formt in OO, though Microsoft is supposed to change this soon.

As for the engineering functions, the engineers I've worked with don't use Excel, regarding it as a piece of crap (they used specialized apps instead). The chemists I've worked with wouldn't have had a problem either as they only used basic multiplication in it on the spreadsheet functions. But they may be exceptions to the rule, as these people were in research.

Funny. MS products get

Funny. MS products get bashed, no matter how good they are. Office 2007 (and office 2008 for Mac) is widely regarded as a huge improvement over previous versions by both professionals and home users. Ofcourse some are not satisfied, but the day every single person will like any given product will never come.

"Microsoft feels the need to constantly re-invent the weel".

Another statement that makes me laugh. MS gets bashed when they release a product that isn't revolutionary (like Vista, some people think it's just a graphical update, i disagree but that's another discussion). Then they release a product that is different from top to bottom... and all of a sudden they have gone too far.

The community is always complaining and will do so as long as MS will exist. Supporting a huge company like MS isn't "cool" and will never be. No matter what product they produce.

Office 2007, an improvement?

I disagree MS Office is a step backwards from previous versions of MS. Where is my selection to go back to the classic view? Why does it not have PDF support by default, whereas OpenOffice has export to PDF support built in? Until MS fixes these problems, I will never like their new office suite. Office 2008 still has a menubar to use as well as a bit different interface and I like how I still have the menubar.

"And if you work in an

"And if you work in an enterprise that's standardized on Microsoft Office, you won't find the program of much use. "

It always suprises me when people in tech blogs make comments like this. I work in a large enterprise that has Microsoft Office on its computers. However, I use OpenOffice on my computers due to familiarity, ease of use and functionality. I have never had issues with lack of function, or with lack of compatibility - aside from the time when, suprise suprise, Microsoft decided to invent a new file format and that caused problems... but what's new there?

In addition many of my colleagues use iWork 08 for their work at home. Again we all work in an MS dominated environment, but all of us have absolutely no reduction in productivity due to using alternative office suites.

OpenOffice offers a very full featured, easy to use and intuitive interface which has the big advantage of familiarity over the 'ribbon' offering of MS.

I hope that one day you will look out of the window and see a much brighter day dawning outside!

if I receive a doc. file (from Microsoft Office)

How do I open a file from Microsoft Office 2007 in my OpenOffice.org page or can I not?
If I can, what do I need to do?
I write and some editors insists on using Microsoft Office when sending atext back with changes. They expect me to also use MOffice to respond, but my preference would be to use OpenOffice and send the revised text in a .doc format. Tks. Marielle

God Bless

The poor sod who has to scurry around installing compatibilty patches to make office 2003 open 2007 and helping near sighted 50 year old accounts secretaries set their save defaults to msoffice why being asked 'why did you break my computer"

End users are complete cnuts to deal with. For the manager and for support staff.

Smart gimps with local admin rights to want install and use their own office versions should be lined up and shot.

Either there are three people and a cat in your company or your just another opinionated home user who has never met the bored pleb in accounting who hates their wok hates IT staff and hates anything that makes them click in a different place to the day before to get their wok done and leave at 5:30.

What would I know though - I was a developer for two major coporations and have my own business supllying services to five SMEs.

I'd like to see you deal with the real angry rude little toejams that populate real world offices and sulk around the place if you ask them to move their seat five inches and the miserably incompetent management that expect it to be both state of the art and free and could not give a toss about how many young smart people spend their lives crawling around offices at night fixing s**t like open office while clerical staff who are pain more stick likeglue to civilised wok hours and go home on time.

You can stick vista, linux et all up you bottom for all the use they are when faced with rude stupid office staff just lookikng for an excuse to dish out abuse.

Don't forget the marketing cock addict with an IPOD full of viri who just has to be allowed install any old sh*t onto a stable network because he nearly made a web site in 1999.

15 years in IT and I hate it.

Go support 200 end users for a year and tell me all about your whizz bang freeware/microsoft junk.

Office apps have offered nothing new that people need for 10 years. People use excel because of mountains of sheets riddles with SQL odbc reporting, macros etc taht for the average SME would take NASA and their budget to make work in anything else.

I hate you all!

For your sins I hope you wind up supporting your favoured tat.