Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


John Brandon's picture
John Brandon

Web 2.0 Watcher

Stupid Chrome bug: Why I'm switching back to Firefox

It doesn't take much to make me hate a browser. After using Chrome for an entire week, I found one seemingly innocuous bug that is so annoying and frustrating that I can't even use the product anymore.

Google normally releases relatively stable betas, but that has not always been the case with "real" software. I remember when Google Desktop Search was first released and it made my PC unusable - I had to reinstall Windows XP. As I said before, this beta is pretty sound - it has not crashed on me at all, and most features work. Chrome does not have any earth-shattering bugs. Or maybe it does?

The bug I found is not so heinous that it will be readily apparent. Yet, it is a killer for me.

Here's how I found it today. I use the inline spell checker a lot. I'm a writer, what can I say? Sometimes, when I right-click to see the correct spelling for a word, Chrome selects all of the text in an e-mail. Fine, a simple SNAFU. It might not seem like a big deal, but if you happen to then click in the wrong place, the "select all" function misfires and clicks on the Undo function. So what does this mean in practical use?

Let's say you type three paragraphs of an e-mail or blog -- your most stunning prose, a technical description for your boss, or this very post. It doesn't have to be in Gmail, so let's say you use Yahoo Mail or Blogger or some other tool. Anyway, if you right-click on a word and the select all function misfires, your text will magically disappear because what you are undoing is actually all of that typing! And there is no way to bring the text back no matter how hard you try. (I have not found a redo function.) It's a killer bug, one that has already lost me about 30 minutes of e-mail typing just today.

(I'm using a Lenovo SL300 laptop with Vista Business, let me know if you can replicate this error in comments.)

so, I have to abandon Chrome for now and go back to Firefox, so we'll see if they fix this problem. In all these years of using Firefox and (gasp, dare I say it) IE I have never had a bug like this. And, I know -- I should be using Word or Outlook, right?


Google Chrome Browser

Related Blogs

What People Are Saying

Everyone that needs to

Everyone that needs to reinstall a OS because a program is a crying noob.

I Love Chrome, But...

I love chrome, but there are few bugs that I wish weren't there.

1. Sometimes I login to citibank.com.ph the window abruptly closes.

2. Sometimes when I type a search in Facebook, even if I already emptied the search field, the letters are still there.

3. Sometimes I can't close Chrome. I don't know.

I haven't yet tried to investigate cause these behaviors are sporadic. My alternative is Firefox.

Chrome is just not designed for non-web-savy users

John Brandon,
Don’t feel too bad about not knowing how to Ctrl-y. It is Google’s fault for designing software that Google Employees can use with ease. They need to remember that, most of them are 10x better with computers then most of the rest of us. I have to admit that I never even noticed that there is no “Redo” Button or even an “Edit Menu” until you mentioned it. I almost always use the hot-keys and so I haven’t looked for cut, copy, paste, undo, redo, or select-all for a really long time. If you use computers for long enough, then you will get the hang of hot-keys, too. Hang in there buddy, some day you will be able to call yourself a “technology writer” and not just a “writer.”

Robert Macon
Contractor

Chrome does have redo!

Ummmm, not to say Chrome doesn't have annoying bugs but Ctrl+y is redo, in virtually any application, including chrome.

Or just right click the text box, and select "redo" from the context menu. (On the context menu it says Ctrl+Shift+z = redo -- but Ctrl+y also works.)

Redo

Redo doesn't work if you just keep typing, like I have every single time. In the few seconds of time when Chrome removes the text, if I don't notice and keep typing after the text removal, the text is gone forever.

RE: Stupid Chrome bug: Why I'm switching back to Firefox

I too have found Chrome unusable for serious, professional Web use:

1.) Chrome does not retain formatting when you copy a page and paste it in another app (e.g., Outlook or Microsoft Word). This is a no-no.

2.) Chrome does not have Print Preview. I print a lot of web pages while doing research. This is another no-no.

3.) Chrome's video playback is spotty at best and completely unusable at worst.

4.) I have seen numerous rendering glitches with printed documents - in other words, lack of WYSIWYG

And I'm all Chrome

Ever since Chrome appeared on my screen, I've used nothing but Chrome, Chrome, Chrome. And Google, Google, Google.

copy paste formatted text

Regarding "1.) Chrome does not retain formatting when you copy a page and paste it in another app (e.g., Outlook or Microsoft Word). This is a no-no."

Sometimes it drives me crazy when IE does this anyhow. In my eyes it's another bonus for Chrome.

Want to know why I hate when IE does it? Because 7 out of 10 times, IE and the target application slow down to a grind for the next minute or so. And about half of those times it does this, those applications become non-recoverable. End task, FTL.

copy paste formatted text in IE

maybe i'm late (almost a year) but..
IE hangs up applications becouse it actually do not copy html/content, but some kind of "pointers" to site/content. so if you paste the text, target application will connect to internet to retreive the content you have copied.

Opera doesnt copy formatting too- and i love it. it depends of personal habits.

the aforementioned Chrome bug

If you're involved in IT, then to be successful (and not suffer the stresses that often accompany cutting-edge technologies), a sense of humor is required. Patience, too.

As a multimedia producer, I must take *all* browser products seriously.

On Mac I prefer Firefox to Safari.

In the Windows environment, I have been switching between Firefox and IE forever (well, Netscape used to factor in too).

Each browser has its strengths and weaknesses.

While I realize that Chrome has *many* bugs yet to be addressed (many having to do with javascript), all I can say is that I'm delighted by its overall performance.

Thanks to borrowing (licensing?) some Apple technologies, the page rendering is FAST. The fastest I've seen on any browser yet.

Also remember that IE has been around since the very beginning of time, Firefox, with the benefits of all the experience that the Mozilla organization have incorporated into its lovely browser - which is far from being 'the new kid on the block'......

......remember that we are dealing with the first Chrome BETA - out only a week !!!

give 'em a little time to pull it together, ok?

In the meantime, it's still: ***different browsers handle certain chores better than others - so use as many as are practical for your optimum productivity!***

Respectfully.

Best to all,

Elliott