Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


David DeJean's picture
David DeJean

Microsoft Logfile

Do UMPCs mean a reprieve for XP?

The approaching forced retirement of Windows XP is a hot topic – see "Windows XP: Going, going ... gone?" But since I wrote that article, developments make me wonder if Microsoft is going to be able to kill off XP.

Two weeks ago Asus announced it expects the new version of its wildly popular Eee ultra-mobile PC (UMPC) with Windows XP Home installed will sell 3 million units this year. Last week Intel rose to the bait and publicly changed its mind about selling its Classmate UMPC in the United States and Europe.

The One Laptop Per Child Foundation is also working with Microsoft to develop a slimmed-down XP to run on its XO laptop. I've been trying out the Everex Cloudbook, an ultra-mobile PC (UMPC) that falls into the same category as the as the Asus Eee and the One Laptop Per Child XO, and I wasn't surprised last week when in the course of an email exchange about the Cloudbook somebody from Everex asked me how I thought the market would react to XP on UMPCs. The Cloudbook, like the XO and the original Eee, runs Linux, but the pressure for Windows seems irresistable.

It's easy to see why Intel would change its mind. The chipmaker was all altruism when it announced the Classmate as a low-cost notebook for schoolchildren in poor countries – though perhaps the fact that the XO didn't run an Intel processor or a Microsoft operating system made the project seem a whole lot less altruistic.

Now along comes the Eee, selling by the millions with a VIA processor installed. And Intel, which had no plans to sell the Classmate in developed countries as recently as January, when I talked to a manager for the Classmate program at CES. But perhaps that was just because Intel didn't (a) have a processor product that fit the category (a problem the new Atom line fixes) and (b) didn't see a market – something the Eee has surely changed its mind about.

The most interesting question now is, what does Microsoft do? These tiny machines all require an operating system a lot less demanding than Windows Vista. But beginning June 30 PC makers are currently expected to stop shipping machines with XP installed. About all Microsoft will have on its shelves to sell is Vista.

The software giant must have given Asus some assurances that make the Taiwanese PC maker believe it can sell XP Home on its bigger, more expensive Eee PCs the rest of this year. And Everex wouldn't be asking about XP if it thought the OS was going away.

But there's a great spectator sport to be had here: How will Microsoft save face while making what looks like an inevitable reversal to keep Windows XP on sale?

There may be some wiggle room in XP Service Pack 3. In the past, Microsoft has supported new service packs for two years or the lifespan of the product the service pack updates, whichever comes first. The company could decide to edit out the "whichever comes first" and give XP SP 3 its allotted two-year span not only of support, but of sales – even though sales and support lifecycles have historically had nothing to do with each other.

Or we could see an entirely new edition of Windows that would basically be a relabeling of XP Home updated with some of Vista's user interface. "Windows Mobile" is already taken, but maybe they could call it "Windows Ultra (Mobile PC)."

Whatever happens, you can bet we'll see Microsoft respond to the current proliferation of extremely popular little computers running Linux. Even if it means the software giant has to grit its teeth and issue an eleventh-hour reprieve for XP.

What People Are Saying

Drivers

Years ago (1995) I played around with Linux. The main argument against using Linux was the lack of hardware support, and the difficulty of installation. I didn't argue the point then because it was true, "I'm not in the business to fight Microsoft" I used to say.
Now we come full circle, the latest Linux distributions have much better hardware support than Vista, and they install easily, without a bunch of hacking to make it work correctly.
I will still use my XP box for games as that is what my games run on. Everything else I do on Linux. Microsoft is the Gaming OS, It's kinda Ironic isn't it?
Linux works better than Vista, it's just that simple.

My new saying:
"I'm not in the business to fight Linux"

The Windows is dead; long live the Linux

When I read the independent trade press surveys about acceptance of Vista (abominable; only half what XP had at the same stage) compared to what Microsoft claims (umpteen gazillion copies), it makes me wonder: is Microsoft living in a different dimension or a parallel universe?

My observation of people who are dedicated PC users is that I believe the trade press surveys -- the only people who think Vista is the greatest invention since sliced bread are the Microsoft kiss-ups who have something to gain and pompous know-nothings quoting Microsoft marketing claims.

I've been around

since the very first PCs. I built and programmed Altair 8800b's in machine code. We used to key the binary in, using switches and the register readout was a bank of LED's. That was the cutting edge, now long gone. Now I am building dual core, quad core, what-nots and loading Linux of every flavor. This is the cutting edge. I'm sorry but you're beloved Windows lies in between, in the past. It's the past, please, just get over it. You're just going to have to learn something new.

On death row,

you only get so many appeals. When Windows has exhausted it's appeals, it'll be it's time to go. These are just the last few appeals.

The hand protruding from the grave...

Windows is dead. Long live Linux. It will be obvious soon enough. I am waiting for the new, larger EeePC. When I get it, I want Linux. Why in the world would I want to keep the blue screen of death, WGA, defiant Automatic updates and all the rest of that drivel? When the last of the "I refuse to learn or change" crowd is swept aside, then will the manifest truth be made apparent...

Inevitable change is coming...

The true and irrevocable change of wind and water on the rocks.

VISTA was DOA

VISTA was a flop. The sooner MS wakes up to that; the sooner we'll have an MS OS worthy of the $$$ to upgrade.

Stay of Execution DENIED!

Microsoft is on Death Row. I doubt if the governor will pardon them for having created XP.

Your article seems to not want to believe what is obvious to all: Linux won.

I completely agree and this

I completely agree and this will be one of the major reasons that XP will continue to have a very long lifespan until at least 7's release.

Underwater,

And sucking air through a straw. There is a Linux tidal wave coming. Look how quickly Linux overwhelmed the Super Computer space. Once the last of the Linux driver issues are corrected and people realize how superior it is, the change will be something. What? "Something Wonderful".

Windows 7 will take about five years to release, then about two years of security patches, bug fixes, service updates, lawsuits, etc. In that space of time, where will Linux be? Everywhere, running everything, uniting and leading mankind into a golden new age of cooperation and peace (lofty music playing in the background).