Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Preston Gralla's picture
Preston Gralla

Seeing Through Windows

What the Vista "Junk PC" suit means for Windows 7 netbooks

Revelations about the "Junk PC" scheme in which Microsoft allowed PCs to be sold as "Vista Capable" even though they couldn't run all the features of Vista make one wonder: What will happen when Windows 7 netbooks hit the market? Will they run all of Windows 7's features, or be partially crippled, as were the "Vista Capable" PCs?

My guess is that Windows 7 netbooks will be fully capable of running all of Windows 7's features. Microsoft has gotten terrible publicity about its "Vista Capable" scheme. The documents in the lawsuit show that Microsoft caved into Intel pressure to launch the scheme, and that HP was furious about the decision.

Microsoft doesn't want similar publicity in the future --- or another lawsuit. This is particularly important when it comes to netbooks, because an estimated 30% of netbooks run Linux. If Microsoft brings out a less-than-full version of Windows 7 on them, it will only make more people choose Linux. And as I've written about in a previous blog, Microsoft is worried that if people get used to Linux on netbooks, they may consider buying it for a desktop PC as well. So the netbook market is too important to gamble with.

In fact, Microsoft has already come out publicly and said that netbooks will run the full version of Windows 7. At the WinHEC keynote address on November 5, Steven Sinofsky, Senior Vice President of Windows and Windows Live, showed off Windows 7 on an ASUS Eee PC. Here's what he said about the machine, and Windows 7:

This one is a 1 gigabyte ram, 16 gig SSD, it's got an Atom dual-core chip in it, 1.6 gigahertz, and it's running full Windows. So you don't have to go down-level, you don't need anything stripped down, this is a full Windows experience on this PC.

He seems to say it pretty clearly --- nothing stripped down, with the "full Windows experience" on a netbook. (By the way, you can read a transcript of the full keynote, here.)

I think Sinofsky's playing straight --- if Microsoft releases a stripped-down version of Windows 7 for netbooks, it could be disastrous, and I think the company knows that.

Preston Gralla is a contributing editor for Computerworld, and the author of more than 35 books.

What People Are Saying

dual-core?

This one is a 1 gigabyte ram, 16 gig SSD, it's got an Atom dual-core chip in it, 1.6 gigahertz, and it's running full Windows. So you don't have to go down-level, you don't need anything stripped down, this is a full Windows experience on this PC.

Has anyone ever found a netbook in the wild with a dual core Atom?

From Intel: the dual-core

From Intel: the dual-core Atom 330 is not for netbooks, but rather desktop atom-based nettops. MS goofed on this one...

http://news.cnet.com/8301-13924_3-10047071-64.html

Linux is free

Preston,

Were those yours or MS's words: "Buy Linux" ??

Sure, you can buy RedHat if you run servers and need 24/7 support, it's available. You can also buy 24/7 support for Ubuntu.

But OS's like Ubuntu (near flawless), CentOS, PCLinux2007, and many, many others are free to download and use for business or personal use!!

Guess using XP Pro and Ubuntu dual boot on my ancient but fine laptop that maxes out at 512 MB ram should be thrown in the trash to buy something that will run Windows 7 Fiesta???

I bought a new Dell last year on eBay that came with Vista and I swear, I think that OS was made to destroy hard drives. Whether i like Vista or not it did it's best to eat my drive.

All I can hear is the thrashing of the hard drive for the first ten minutes after pressing the power button. That's with Indexing turned off and 2 GB of ram.

Slim it down MS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Quote: Microsoft is worried

Quote: Microsoft is worried that if people get used to Linux on netbooks, they may consider buying it for a desktop PC as well.

Lol! "buying" Linux?!

buy Liux

Downloading a cd's worth of Linux operating system could take 24 hours on dialup; There is a chance of errors or dropped connections also. Linux cd's of ones choice of operating system is available for a nominal fee of 5 to 10 bucks, maybe a little more for shipping. This is for a no support version. This price is worth it to some people who value their time to be worth the same. You can "buy" supported Linux for your distribution of choice for prices of $50-$100 depending on the support. You don't buy a license - true; you receive a license (GPL) for no dollars but you have performance obligations with it.

I think they mean buying a

I think they mean buying a PC with Linux instead of Windows.
Most computer users are not confident installing windows themselves never mind linux but a £200 computer with Ubuntu and a 1/2 year support & warranty would convert alot of people happy with the linux experience on their EeePc

When has Microsoft delivered what they said they would?

(NT)