Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Seth Weintraub's picture
Seth Weintraub

Apple versus Google

Ten areas where Google's Android could make waves vs. Apple's iPhone

Apple's i(Hesus)Phone is a fantastic and groundbreaking device. But, as much as I hate to say it isn't perfect and has its share of shortcomings. It hasn't really mattered too much because no Windows Mobile, Blackberry, Palm or Symbian phone has come close in terms of usability and features. Google's Android OS, which is set to be announced on Tuesday, has the backing of the Google behemoth and has generated much buzz in the press. Will it have usability and features to match the iPhone? Perhaps, perhaps not. Google's OS and the hardware manufactures have yet to release any reliable specs.

Here are some openings in which Google's Android phones could win over some potential customers from Apple:

1. Instant messaging addicts. iPhone's IM capabilities are suspiciously weak. Third party products like IM+ and others fill this gap to an extent but I still had a better client on my Tmobile sidekick three years ago. Apple's late release of Push Notification may help some of these apps behave in a way that is more like a desktop client (running in the background). My current favorite is Fring which I used on my jailbroken 1.1.4 iPhone with great success. If Google can get a Fring-type of application on the Android, the Android will be a superior IM phone, hands down. Also audio/video chatting and VoIP could be more robust.

2. Video recording - You can jailbreak your iPhone and use Cycorder which is really easy and straightforward - but for people who are hesitant to do this, you are currently stuck. Chances are Google will allow you to record video out of the box. Google might even let you do broadcasting which you can do with a jailbroken iPhone using Qik but doesn't appear to be within Apple's crosshairs.

I recorded the birth of my son on an iPhone using Qik video and broadcast it live to friends and familyWhat a great experience.  Apple won't let you have this unless you choose to jailbreak your iPhone.  Google will.

3. Camera - a better camera that comes close to a point and click. Apple's two megapixel camera is good for phone pictures but phones like Nokia's N96 have been significantly better than iPhone for a long time - and even have a small (sometimes ineffective) flash. If Google throws in a 4 megapixel camera, it might make a difference for some people.

4. Carrier Choice - If you want T-mobile over AT&T for instance, Android's the way to go. You might even be able to buy an unlocked version and put other SIM cards in it - which saves a lot of money when roaming. With iPhone 3G, you are with the carrier you bought it with. For some, this is reason enough to go with the Android.

5. A physical keyboard will always be better than a virtual one for some. If this is you, Android beats iPhone in this department.

6. You are a Linux loving tinkerer. The Linux-based Android OS will be infinitely more flexible for those hard core geeks who want to mess with the way their phones act. The level of access Google will give you is still unknown, but the source of Android will be available for your perusal.

7. Stereo Bluetooth. This is one of those things that Apple could flick on at any moment. The iPhone hardware already supports it. Apple has so far neglected to do so. Some think that A2DP drains the power too quickly. Also, syncing over Bluetooth would be nice.

8. SMS Multimedia Messaging. For me this isn't an issue. I think SMS is just a way for phone companies to squeeze a few more bucks out of consumers. This functionality can largely be replicated with email or (hopefully soon) with IM. However, even though its days are numbered, many people still love to use SMS for sending pictures. If this is you, you might be a Google Android candidate.


Google Android demo

9. Flash/Java support. Android probably won't support these technologies out of the box but it has a much higher likelihood of supporting them in the long run...I think. If you need these two technologies, an iPhone might not be right for you.

10. There are those who don't like Apple's closed ecosystem - and there are valid points to be made. Google's product is based on an open source model which allows more transparency into the workings of the system. Most people also agree that Google will be much more open to what goes into the device as well. There will be more choice in Email application, web browser, etc. You also aren't locked to the iTunes ecosystem. The Android may be a stand-alone device. This will probably lead to wider adoption by more companies. Will the quality of those applcations be better than iPhone? It remains to be seen.

Having written the list, I kind of feel like I was writing a "You might be a redneck if.." Jeff Foxworthy joke. "You might be an Android customer."

But in all seriousness, there are many valid reasons to consider the Android over the iPhone. I am just curious about the tech as a gadget guy...does that count?

What People Are Saying

Yet you said that N97 is a

Yet you said that N97 is a failure, while N97 is arguably better than Android

Palringo

Hi Seth

I would like to invite you to try Palringo on the iPhone. It's the only multi-IM client that combines both text, voice and images.

In addition, we have also introduced a feature to cater for the lack of background application support which is unique

And, in our most recent update, we have added the following features.

* Unread private messages now saved on exit
* Progress bars when sending/receiving voice/photos
* Reduced network usage (we are now using compression so logging in over EDGE/GPRS/3G should be noticeably faster)
* Support for Y! Japan
* Support for SSL/TLS on XMPP (Jabber/GTalk)
* Russian language translation
* Spam filtering for non-Palringo services (MSN/ICQ/etc)
* Ability to disable predictive input
* Ability to set the default status to ‘Away/Busy’ when leaving Palringo (while the server keeps you connected)
* Remembers your status on all services (MSN/ICQ/etc)

There are even more changes planned in the following weeks.

And or course we are working on a version of Palringo for the Android platform, so stay tuned.

best regards
Kerry Ritz
CEO
Palringo

Camera and Storage

The camera looks like it was announced as 3MP. While better than the iPhone's, its not a hell of a lot better. Not enough to sway people over to it, at least I would be surprised if it was.

And for video recording, the G1 comes with 1GB of storage expandable to 8GB. not exactly a lot, at most half the current iPhone max. With music and apps, how much room would you have to do video recording?

Dweeb #2

The comment, which contained nothing but an insult, was removed.

Santa Claus

... and next time I see someone invoking the name of Santa Claus in vain, and even daring to suggest he does not fly through the air distributing presents, I will instantly complain to the editor and ensure the article is changed.

Please, please don't give in to the superstitious primitives in this country. They have more than enough power already.

Think you missed the point

Hi Chris,

Who's primitive? If all you can do is mock others - your manners are as bad as Dweeb #1 & #2.

Also, if you had actually spent any time reading the rest of my post, you'd realize my editorial comment was also based on a pretty major lack of facts and that he missed an obvious DATE of release. (Which is TODAY BTW, not Monday). That's just plain shoddy journalism. Sorry you feel so threatened as to the first part of the post. I'll pray for you to find peace.

Best regards...Bob

Surprised @ Low Level of Editorial Quality

+1 on using Jesus' name in vain. Come ON dude - playing search engine games or what?!!? (and yes, I was offended slightly, but more concerned with the disregard of others' beliefs in a major print publication).

To the two dweebs that can't seem to understand the concept of intelligence vs. good manners - I'll leave you both to fume and feel threatened by a simple request. You might also consider that intelligent discussions can still be attained without trashing others beliefs.

Seth - pull your head out and read something other that your own blather. If you had spent ANY time researching some of the various Android news 'leaks' in the past 2 weeks, you'd see several mentions of actual features rather than stuff you simply pulled out of the air. Actual pictures of the G1 instead of a mockup, leaked features of the G1, etc.

Also, WHY would you say that the announcement is on Monday, when it's tomorrow? (Tuesday)

This article smacks of last minute deadline and incredibly shoddy preparation. GIGO = Garbage In Garbage Out.

Like I said to the others,

Like I said to the others, this is more about ways in which Google could exploit the shortcomings of the iPhone, not a best guess list of Android features.

Apologies to everyone offended by the "Jesus phone". My understanding was that this term was part of the common vernacular. I've changed it.

Big Change - continue onward

Yeah Seth, that's really a nice change...continue onward being politically incorrect.

So why the apology if the spirit of term is still there? Just more of the same. Me thinks you missed the point here. Better go back to journalism 101.

James - Jesus Request

"Also, please be sensitive to those whose Lord's name you are taking in vain. I'm sure I'm not the only one who is offended by this."

While agreeing with the request, it is interesting how a simple request could immediately elicit hostility and name-calling...also posted anonymously.

Hmmmmm.