Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Seth Weintraub's picture
Seth Weintraub

Apple versus Google

Why did Apple pull iPhone 2.1's push notification?

Apple pulled the push notification feature of its iPhone 2.1 software in the last pre-release beta version that it seeded to developers. This would have made applications like instant message services much better than they are currently because they would have the ability to operate in the background while the iPhone is asleep or on another application.

Why? Common sense would dictate that it was pulled because Apple wasn't sure it could be stable by the time 2.1 was final. Apple was already reeling from the instabilities in the first few revisions of its iPhone 2.0 software and its customers wanted something more stable.

But there could be another reason. Perhaps Apple is hiding something?

Apple is expected to have a "big deal" launch tomorrow. The push notification system could be tied to many parts of a new hardware product's internals. Perhaps a tablet or wearable computer? Or mayb just a modestly updated iPod Touch. Apple would want to hide this from the lion's share of developers.

Also, Apple may be introducing some other functionality to its devices that may be intertwined with push. Maps for a turn by turn application - perhaps push traffic? Or how about push for a VoIP application? What if Apple was launching on another type of network (CDMA Verizon, Sprint?) and some of the new push elements made reference to this?

A more sinister rationale? Perhaps AT&T bigwigs were worried that a full push instant messaging client would prevent them from selling as many of their lucrative $15/month unlimited texting plans as they currently are selling. Delaying a good instant messaging client as long as they have on the iPhone is already highly suspicious.

Finally for gaming ... Apple is suspected of working with 24 Hour Fitness on Excer-gaming on the iPhone platform ... wouldn't that be interesting?

Or, I could be entirely wrong and the cut off could be for stability. It's strange that Apple has kept this omission quiet until the event -- not the best place in the world to break bad news.

I guess we'll see soon.

What People Are Saying

IPhone

the IPhone is being trashed in Japan because it is seen as primarily a 'game' machine not for serious communications such as for texters and instant messaging and emails. I was there for two months, didn't see a single IPhone burt every single person, from a 72-year-old to the school kids carried cell phones(I can't think of one exception) and they used them all the time for texting, emails, and calling. I had one as did my three kids and spouse and used them all the time - the software in Japanese phones allows them to display in English.

Games were more often played at home or in the pachinko 'parlors', which are huge (in size, rivalling the supermarkets for floor space, and popularity).

background

Get a Symbian phone and you can run apps in the background, including any number of IM clients.

Mac release. New spell checker?

'not the best place in the wold to reak bad news.'
Pardon?

heh. late night blogging

heh. late night blogging not recommended...Updated

Think globally ...

"Perhaps AT&T bigwigs were worried that a full push instant messaging client would prevent them from selling as many of their lucrative $15/month unlimited texting plans as they currently are selling."

AT&T is not the only carrier in the world with the iPhone. So I doubt Apple will ever do something to please AT&T only. Some carrier already provide unlimited texting (or nearly unlimited : 1000) so this is irrelevant.

In norway it will cost you

In norway it will cost you almost us$ 3000 for a 16 gb 3g Iphone with the 1000 sms a month deal. So I think it is relevant...

Secondly, the push

Secondly, the push notification is huge part of the SDK and Apple has already annouced it.
Since no application can run in background, system wide push service is a important and structuring part of the iPhone API.

Apple will not pull down such a feature just to please a few carriers on such casual things such as text messages.

2.1 Update experience

I am having good luck so far with the 2.1 update if the results I'm getting are actually correct. Five bars on signal strength and really quick backup speeds.

Charlie
www.tengallonbrain.com
(Read about my iPhone update experience here)