Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Mike Elgan's picture
Mike Elgan

The World Is My Office

Why every laptop should come with a universal flash key

Sony announced this week that it plans to distribute movies and music on USB flash drives, as an alternative to DVDs and Blu-Ray disks. It's a novel idea, but one that raises a question: Why is Sony bothering with entertainment when it could be using flash drives to dramatically improve laptop data security?

On the one hand, the distribution of media on flash drives is a solution to a problem that does not exist. Nobody is clamoring for alternatives to disc- and online-media distribution.

On the other hand, laptop data security is the Mother of All problems for everyone with a laptop. Laptops can get stolen, damaged, lost or breached, which sucks. Anybody that travels regularly on business has experienced one or more of these horrible events.

Right now, it's the responsibility for individuals or the companies they work for to cobble together security solutions which, at the end of the day, end up failing. The IT admins responsible for the contrivance of these kludges are primarily interested in protecting the companies' precious data. But what about the hapless road warrior? If his Laptop goes South halfway through a two-week road trip, he's toast. Sure, the data he had before he left is mostly recoverable in the best of circumstances. But what about that lost week of reports, e-mail, presentations and other data? What's he to do for the reamaining week?

There's got to be a better way. And, in fact, there is.

I believe that, like automobiles, every new laptop should come with two "keys" that are required in order to use the product. These laptop keys should be USB flash drives that perform the following functions:

1. Access control. Instead of an easily hackable password, the laptop should be protected by the existence of the specific keys. No key, no access. The beauty of a USB drive is that it can fit on a key chain or in a pocket. That way, if the whole laptop bag is lost or stolen en route, the access key won't go with it.

2. User ID. The USB keys should have fingerprint readers on them which the user must use to identify himself or herself. This is different than fingerprint readers on existing laptops, which don't provide additional security (they typically only add convenience, and don't replace password ID).

3. System restore. In the old days, PCs and laptops came with restore disks. Nowadays, that stuff is usually dropped on a partition on the system disk itself. By installing it on the USB key, the settings could be retained on the key, and the installation could happen with all user settings in place. It would also reduce mix-ups with restoring on a new system or a new drive, because it would definitely contain the OS and apps that were installed on the original drive.

4. Backup and recovery. The key should be set by default to do occasional full and frequent incremental backups of all user data. Because the key would be required in order to use the laptop, this backup drive would always be available to the backup system.

5. Key backup. By inserting the second laptop key in a second USB drive, the first drive could be mirrored periodically to the second, in case the first is lost. Both are encrypted, and both require a key provided by the laptop manufacturer in order to read the data.

I'm not sure if this system is ideal, but I do know the current "system" fails. Tools and technologies are scattered to the wind and hundreds or thousands of people lose vital data every day because nothing like this exists.

Sony makes Vaio laptops. Instead of dorking around with publicity stunt initiatives that put Hi-Def movies on flash drives, why don't they instead use those flash drives to solve the problem that everyone has: how to protect data on a laptop.

RSS feed icon Like this stuff? Subscribe to the RSS feed.

What People Are Saying

USB flash keys are unreliable

Do not rely on usb flash sticks, they can fail any moment. They are actually only meant for temporary backup and transfer to other computers. I can imagine sitting on the train, connecting the required flash key, when it suddenly doesn't work anymore.
There is actually no solution to the problem of theft because a thief can easily remove the hard drive from a laptop and put it in an external case to access the data. No fingerprint scanner will stop them either.
If you have sensitive data, remove it before you travel. Never create documents with passwords or credit card details on your laptop. Use a paper notebook instead and guard it like you guard your wallet.

USB keys

I'm currently only keeping applications on my laptop's drive.
All my personal data is saved on an external flash drive. I don't have a lot.
Maybe I'm missing the point.

This is neither a new idea

This is neither a new idea nor a dream - you can buy this exact Solution since a long time - just have a look at: http://www.mcafee.com/us/medium/products/data_loss_prevention/encrypted_usb.html

and
http://www.mcafee.com/us/medium/products/data_loss_prevention/endpoint_encryption.html

Good idea

Thats only one problem : if i forget my flash key, How could i get it back? Or how could i reset it.

Password

"easily hackable passwords" ??? I think anyone able to not lose the USB key should also have the basic ability to pick and remember a reasonable password. They are not easily hackable. This article reeks of ignorance.

Built-in fingerprint scanner

What does this solution provide that a built-in fingerprint scanner cannot? If the fingerprint scanner behaved like a BIOS password (so the system couldn't boot) and harddrive decryption key (so data couldn't be retrieved), then it seems like all the problems are solved.

The exception is the data backup which is simply not feasible.

Not mutually exclusive

The entertainment vs. security question simply doesn't make sense. Why would Sony's entertainment divisions get into the security game? Your suggestions make sense, but if they were delivered it would be completely separate to their decisions around media distribution.

Also, shouldn't the USB distribution idea be given some consideration before being dismissed? For instance: a USB key is reusable. As we move towards broader acceptance of digital media and home servers, DVDs become environmentally wasteful. Or what about picking up a movie at a vending machine (USB keys could fit in smaller boxes) at the airport gate? And think about the different form factor, energy efficiency and noise level of a device that doesn't require a DVD player. Etc.

The device you are looking

The device you are looking for is called an IronKey https://www.ironkey.com/

Yeah, USB keys sure can't be

Yeah, USB keys sure can't be used for backup now. We've got laptops out there with 200GB hard drives, but there's nothing even approximating a 200GB USB key, and if there were it'd be so expensive no one could own one.

A far better solution as far as backup goes I think is online/incremental backup, like with something like SugarSync (which is super helpful for multiple machines anyway, which business users are much more likely to encounter) or Mozy or similar services.

I also agree with those users discounting USB keys. I work in the graphic design industry, which means I have 2 different programs that must use a USB key to function. I've had umpteen problems with both, BECAUSE of the USB keys; I'd have far more freedom and fewer problems with long, arbitrary username/password combinations than the USB keys. I rue them, rue them so hard.

Also, the laptop I'm typing this on is little over a year old, and all 3 USB ports on it are loose and provide intermittent connections already.

This guy never lost a USB

This guy never lost a USB key?