Industry


Ads by TechWords

See your link here


Subscribe to our e-mail newsletters
For more info on a specific newsletter, click the title. Details will be displayed in a new window.
Computerworld Daily News (First Look and Wrap-Up)
Computerworld Blogs Newsletter
The Weekly Top 10
More E-Mail Newsletters 
Dan Tynan's picture
Dan Tynan

Culture Crash

Today's Internet has been brought to you by porn

After a wild and passionate youth, YouTube and Ning have both announced they're adopting a policy of abstinence. Heck, they might even join a convent. Why? Money, of course.

Ning is saying sayanora to its Red Light District, the adult section of the DIY social networking site. Come January 1 they're kicking the call girls to the curb and putting a crimp on pimps. (Memo to Marc Andreessen: I mean that metaphorically – please don't sue me.)

YouTube has just announced new policies designed to keep quasi-smutty videos from rising to the top of its pages. The underlying reason in both cases is these sites desperately want to win the hearts of mainstream advertisers, who don't want their ads appearing in the same neighborhood as The Pussykat Theater and Wicked Wanda's House of Devilish Delites.

YouTube just released new rules about what it considers "sexually suggestive" videos that are comical in their prudishness. Besides nudity and actual sex, videos may be age-restricted if they “feature individuals in minimal or revealing clothing... [or] if they're intended to elicit a sexual response.”

Other considerations?

  • Whether breasts, buttocks, or genitals are the "focal point" of the video. So much for the BootyTown Channel.

  • Whether the video is set in a location "associated with sexual activity, such as a bed." Because as we all know, people only have sex in bed.

  • Poses intended to sexually arouse the viewer. I dunno; that upavistha januparivrttasana yoga position always gets me hot.

  • Actions that suggest "a willingness to engage in sexual activity." Ideally, both the video's creators and its viewers will have been married to each other for at least 10 years, so the issue will never come up.

  • Minimal clothing is acceptable, but only in appropriate contexts. That micro-thong bikini? No sweat if you're poolside, but better grab a towel before you step inside the kitchen.

In other words, to comply with YouTube's age-restricted standards you'd pretty much have to be dressed as a nun sitting in an uncomfortable chair with your legs crossed while thinking pure thoughts.

Talk about kinky.

In practical terms these restrictions do nothing to protect the youth of America from having their sensibilities warped by hot booties and thong bikinis. YouTube merely requires you to create an account and say "Yes, I am 18 or older" before showing you the goods. That's just a joke, and not a funny one.

The bigger effect is that YouTube is tweaking its algorithms to bury all that highly popular yet suggestive stuff down in the search results. The Vicar is on the doorstep and they've got 30 seconds to stash those copies of Barely Legal in the basement.

It's no secret that, like the Internet itself, YouTube used sex to reach critical mass. The most popular v-bloggers are invariably the ones who display their assets, and I don't mean their stock portfolios. So now, after fooling around with the neighborhood strumpet for four years, YouTube wants to toss her aside and marry the Vicar's daughter.

Understandable? Sure. Hypocritical? Just a wee bit.

It's a cliché that the Web was built on the back of the beast with two backs. Some 15 years later, just how much of the Net is porn today varies wildly depending on whom you ask. Optenet, a content filtering service based in Spain, released a survey in September that claimed roughly 35 percent of Web sites contain pornographic content. (It made other, more troubling claims that I'll talk about in a future blog post.)

That survey has many problems, not the least of which is that it underestimates the size of the Internet by a few orders of magnitude (in my humble, not-a-professional-statistician opinion). I asked Charles Renert, senior director of advanced content research at Websense, how much of the Net is porn. His best guess is that the percentage of porn sites is in the single digits. (He also agrees that Optenet's estimate of the Net's size is way off.) But Renert says that yardstick is irrelevant. What matters is where people go. And about 80 percent of the Net's traffic goes to the top 100 sites (including YouTube), says Renert.

Though porn is increasingly less of a presence on the Net - and increasingly less profitable for its purveyors, due to the explosion of free adult content - it helped spur the adoption of ecommerce, online payment systems, broadband connections, streaming and live video, and much more. I'll be writing more about this soon here and elsewhere, so stay tuned.

Ning and YouTube might try to bury their shady past, but they can't escape it. The real question is whether they can thrive - or even survive – without it.

Do you dig YouTube's seamier side? Will you go elsewhere for your red light desires? Weigh in below or email me direct: dan (at) dantynan (dot) com.

Dan Tynan subscribes to the BootyTown Channel, but only to read the comments. The rest of the time he tends his blogs, Culture Crash and Tynan on Tech.

What People Are Saying

How to keep my kids eyes safe

35% of the internet being porn is a really scary number.. hopefully that is massivly inflated. For the families that want to protect their children from all the adult material online I'd suggest any of these products for web filtering.. All of which I've heard great things about from friends and articles - and I currently use Livia..

Livia Web Protection
NetNanny
K9 Web Protection
Safe Eyes

Shades of Billy Boy

Dan Tynan subscribes to the BootyTown Channel, but only to read the comments.

Yeah, and he probably doesn't inhale, either.

actually....

I don't exhale. that way nothing gets wasted (except me, of course).

cheers,

dt

Internet porn is turning

Internet porn is turning your daughters into hookers and your sons into desensitized jerks. Porn screws with people's ability to have meaningful, intimate interaction with another person. It's like those mice who keep pushing the button for sugar water until they die. Men and boys just keep pushing the porn button until they lose all perspective and are completely unacceptable partners for any female. I'm all for putting some kind of gates on this crap so that parents stand a chance of raising kind and responsible human beings instead of sex obsessed morons.

and I always thought it was

bad parenting that turned our daughters into hookers and sons into desensitized jerks. you mean I can now blame something vague and external for my failings? terrific.

seriously, this blog post is not meant as an argument for porn. it's meant to show how defining what is and isn't 'suggestive' is purt-near impossible when you get right down to it. and also how -- like most of the commercial world -- youtube uses sex to sell itself, then gets all righteous about it later.

cheers,

dt

Dan Tynan
Tynan on Tech
dantynan.com

Crazy

Amazing what Ning has done, 30 day notice to people have been paying Ning to have their site up on ning. Now that Nings raised a lot of money they said get out to the people that paid their rent when no one was paying to be on Ning ..

I have answer for the Fathers please put controls on your computer so your child will not find any adults site. Not all adult sites are porn and a lot of the adult site are about saving lives and giving out information to people that could get hurt. The internet is not a baby sitter for your child and we all have to take responsibly and my site that was on Ning had two place where it stated that you have to over the age of 18 and meg tags so your child could not enter.

I have 30 days to rebuild a new site and no word from Ning if I'm going to get my thousands of photos, videos, blogs, forums,members passwords, members pages and so much more. All of this was gone in one E-mail

So you tell me is this right? I do believe that adults have the right to see what they want in their bedrooms and homes, we have lost so much of our freedom, not all nude photos are porn a lot are art and tell me when are we going to start burning books again ... Or maybe we should have all the women wear burkas

Merry Xmas Ning

Photo Backup and Migration Tool for Ning Site Owners

In response to Ning's claim that they are "working now on figuring out a way to ensure that all Adult content is available for export before (all adult sites are turned off on) January 1st", we have the following solution:

http://www.widgetlaboratory.com/members/profile/1/blog-view/lab-ninja---backup-and-migrate-your-ning-photos_64.html

WidgetLaboratory is very familiar with Ning's method of "dealing" with customer relationships by way of obfuscation and finger-pointing. The truth behind the words is often hard to find.

Any reasonable person should ask the question: If we could do this from outside of Ning, in such a short time.. how hard could it really be for Ning to deliver a full migration tool to Network Creators BEFORE they are deleted from Ning?

Women in burkas

(pant, pant!)

Women in pants

(burka, burka)

Dan Tynan
Tynan on Tech
dantynan.com

Great New Product to Protect

Great New Product to Protect Kids From Online Dangers. www.MySurfAlert.net Great Low Price! First Product to have a lot of Interesting New Features. Keep Your Kids Safe From Potential Online Predators and Cyber Bullying. A Great Product. A Must To Try!